Saved copy of
Ohio's 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records
cleveland.com · 2023-01-05
<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="en"><head><meta charSet="utf-8"/><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1, minimum-scale=1"/><link rel="preload" as="image" imageSrcSet="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=500&smart=true&quality=90 500w, https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=800&smart=true&quality=90 800w, https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90 1280w" imageSizes="(max-width: 500px) 100vw, (max-width: 800px) 80vw, 60vw" fetchPriority="high"/><script type="text/javascript" id="sophi-loader" fetchPriority="high" src="https://cdn.sophi.io/assets/demeter/1/stable/1545932337.js?isConsented=true" async=""></script><script src="https://js.datadome.co/tags.js" async=""></script><meta name="isArticleBeta" property="isArticleBeta" content="true"/><link rel="icon" type="image/x-icon" href="/pf/resources/images/cleveland/favicon.ico?d=1703"/><link rel="manifest" href="/pf/resources/manifest/cleveland/manifest.json?d=1703"/><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge,chrome=1"/><meta name="robots" content="max-image-preview:large"/><title>Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records - cleveland.com</title><meta name="robots" content="noarchive, nocache"/><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge,chrome=1"/><meta name="title" content="Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records"/><meta property="fb:admins" content="100000302287435"/><meta property="fb:app_id" content="125188170846713"/><meta property="og:title" content="Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records"/><meta property="og:url" content="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html"/><meta property="og:site_name" content="cleveland"/><meta property="og:type" content="article"/><meta property="article:published_time" content="2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z"/><meta property="article:modified_time" content="2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z"/><meta property="article:section" content="News"/><meta property="article:tag" content="@lll,@yyy,ohio-senate-race-2022,ohio-senate-race-2024"/><meta name="twitter:title" content="Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records"/><meta name="twitter:site" content="@clevelanddotcom"/><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/><meta name="article_publication_name" content="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html"/><meta name="article_date_original" content="Thursday, January 05, 2023, 10:00 AM"/><meta name="article_date_updated" content="Thursday, January 05, 2023, 10:00 AM"/><meta name="sailthru.tags" content="news,republicans,campaigns and campaign finance,lobbying and advocacy,democrats,congressional elections,ohio-senate-race-2022,ohio-senate-race-2024"/><meta name="sailthru.date" content="Thursday, January 05, 2023, 10:00 AM"/><meta name="sailthru.title" content="Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records"/><meta name="sailthru.author" content="andrewjtobias"/><meta name="sailthru.description" content="This year, $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups. That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three Senate races combined."/><meta name="machine_tags" content="@lll,@yyy"/><meta name="byline" content="Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com"/><meta name="subscriber_only" content="false"/><meta name="sections" content="news,open,politics"/><meta name="subsections" content="Ohio Politics,National Politics"/><meta name="trackonomics.section" content="News"/><meta name="trackonomics.author" content="Andrew Tobias"/><meta name="trackonomics.author_id" content="andrewjtobias"/><link rel="canonical" href="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html"/><link rel="amphtml" href="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html?outputType=amp"/><link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Cleveland.com" href="https://www.cleveland.com/arc/outboundfeeds/rss/category/news/?outputType=xml"/><meta name="Description" content="This year, $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups. That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three Senate races combined."/><meta property="og:description" content="This year, $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups. That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three Senate races combined."/><meta name="twitter:description" content="This year, $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups. That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three Senate races combined."/><link rel="image_src" href="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90"/><meta name="twitter:image" content="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90"/><meta property="og:image" content="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90"/><meta property="og:image:width" content="1280"/><meta property="og:image:height" content="720"/><meta property="article:author" content="https://www.facebook.com/andrewjtobias"/><meta name="article_author" content="Andrew Tobias | atobias@cleveland.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://fonts.gstatic.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://adservice.google.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://as.jivox.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://c.amazon-adsystem.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://www.google.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://cdn.taboola.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://as-sec.casalemedia.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://aax.amazon-adsystem.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://fastlane.rubiconproject.com"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://cdn.cookielaw.org"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://tags.crwdcntrl.net"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://bcp.crwdcntrl.net"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://cdn.blueconic.net"/><meta name="arc-id" content="TGEUPTW2X5GK3EGJZHV43ABBNY"/><link id="fusion-output-type-styles" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/pf/dist/components/output-types/default.css?d=1703&mxId=00000000"/><link id="fusion-template-styles" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/pf/dist/components/combinations/default.css?d=1703&mxId=00000000"/><link rel="stylesheet" href="/pf/resources/dist/cleveland/css/style.css?d=1703"/><script type="application/javascript" id="polyfill-script">if(!Array.prototype.includes||!(window.Object && window.Object.assign)||!window.Promise||!window.Symbol||!window.fetch){document.write('<script type="application/javascript" src="/pf/dist/engine/polyfill.js?d=1703&mxId=00000000" defer=""><\/script>')}</script><script id="fusion-engine-react-script" type="application/javascript" src="/pf/dist/engine/react.js?d=1703&mxId=00000000" defer=""></script><script id="fusion-engine-combinations-script" type="application/javascript" src="/pf/dist/components/combinations/default.js?d=1703&mxId=00000000" defer=""></script><link href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Inter:ital,opsz,wght@0,14..32,100..900;1,14..32,100..900&family=Noto+Serif:ital,wght@0,100..900;1,100..900&display=swap" rel="stylesheet"/><script type="application/ld+json">[{
"@context": "http://schema.org",
"@type": "NewsArticle",
"mainEntityOfPage": [{"@type": "WebPage", "@id": "https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html"}],
"isAccessibleForFree": "True",
"hasPart": {
"@type": "WebPageElement",
"isAccessibleForFree": "True",
"cssSelector": ".main"
},
"isPartOf": {
"@type": ["CreativeWork", "Article", "NewsArticle", "Product"],
"name": "cleveland.com"
,"productID": "cleveland.com:cleve"
},
"headline": "Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records",
"url": "https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html",
"thumbnailUrl": "https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90",
"image": ["https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90","https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=800&smart=true&quality=90","https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=500&smart=true&quality=90","https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=180&smart=true&quality=90"],
"dateCreated": "2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z",
"datePublished": "2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z",
"dateModified": "2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z",
"publisher": [{
"@type": "Organization",
"name": "cleveland",
"logo": [{"@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://static.advance.net/static/cleve/static/img/logos/logo_main.png"}]
}],
"creator": [{"@type":"Person","name":"Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com","email":"atobias@cleveland.com","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/staff/andrewjtobias/"}],
"author": [{"@type":"Person","name":"Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com","email":"atobias@cleveland.com","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/staff/andrewjtobias/"}],
"keywords": "@lll,@yyy,ohio-senate-race-2022,ohio-senate-race-2024,section:/news",
"articleSection": "News",
"metadata": [{
"blog_id": "/news",
"entry_id": "arc-TGEUPTW2X5GK3EGJZHV43ABBNY",
"short_title": "Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records",
"image_url": "https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90",
"author_name": "",
"author_nickname": "",
"source_blog_name": "News",
"source_blog_url": "https://cleveland.com/news",
"sponsored_content": "0",
"ampurl": "https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html?outputType=amp"
}]
}]</script><script id="sophi-init">
window.sophi = window.sophi || {};
sophi.demeter = { actions: [] };
window.demeter = window.demeter || function () {
var resolve, reject;
const s = new Promise((res, rej) => {
resolve = res, reject = rej;
});
sophi.demeter.actions.push([arguments, resolve, reject]);
return s;
};
</script><script id="fides-js">!function(){window.fides_overrides={fides_consent_non_applicable_flag_mode:"include",fides_consent_flag_type:"boolean"};addEventListener("FidesReady",function(){function getCookieValue(name){try{var match=document.cookie.match("(^|;)\\s*"+name+"\\s*=\\s*([^;]+)");var cookieValue=match?.pop();return cookieValue?JSON.parse(decodeURIComponent(cookieValue)):null}catch(e){return null}}function writeCookie(name,value,domain,opts={}){var{path:path="/",expires:expires}=opts;let cookie=`${name}=${encodeURIComponent(JSON.stringify(value))}; path=${path}`;if(domain)cookie+=`; domain=${domain}`;if(expires)cookie+=`; expires=${new Date(expires).toUTCString()}`;document.cookie=cookie;return true}function getTopViableDomain(){var testName="fides_test_"+Date.now();var VALUE={test:"fides"};var hostnameParts=window.location.hostname.split(".");let topViableDomain="";for(let i=1;i<=hostnameParts.length;i++){topViableDomain=hostnameParts.slice(-i).join(".");var testExpiration=new Date;testExpiration.setFullYear(testExpiration.getFullYear()+1);writeCookie(testName,VALUE,topViableDomain,{expires:testExpiration});var savedCookie=getCookieValue(testName);if(savedCookie?.test===VALUE.test){writeCookie(testName,"",topViableDomain,{expires:new Date(0)});break}}return topViableDomain}var topViableDomain=getTopViableDomain();var fidesConsentCookie=getCookieValue("fides_consent");var previouslyOptedOut=fidesConsentCookie?.consent?.targeted_advertising_gpp_us_state===false||fidesConsentCookie?.consent?.sales_sharing_targeted_advertising_gpp_us_national===false;var oldMarketingOptOutNotConverted=Fides.fides_meta?.converted_consent===undefined;if(oldMarketingOptOutNotConverted&&previouslyOptedOut){fidesConsentCookie.consent.marketing=false;fidesConsentCookie.fides_meta.converted_consent={label:"has_converted",value:true};var updatedAt=Fides?.fides_meta?.updatedAt;var updatedTimestamp=updatedAt?new Date(updatedAt):new Date;updatedTimestamp.setFullYear(updatedTimestamp.getFullYear()+1);writeCookie("fides_consent",fidesConsentCookie,topViableDomain,{expires:updatedTimestamp})}var marketingNoticeKey;for(var i=0;i<Fides?.experience?.privacy_notices?.length;i++){var pn=Fides?.experience?.privacy_notices[i];if(pn.notice_key==="marketing"){marketingNoticeKey=pn.notice_key;break}}if(marketingNoticeKey&&Fides.consent?.marketing===true&&Fides.saved_consent?.marketing===false){Fides.updateConsent({consent:{...Fides.consent,marketing:false}})}});addEventListener("FidesInitialized",function(){Fides.blueconic();Fides.gtm()});addEventListener("FidesUpdating",function(){Fides.fides_meta.consented_geolocation={label:"Location",value:Fides.geolocation.location};if(Fides.fides_meta?.converted_consent&&event.detail?.consent?.sales_sharing_targeted_advertising_gpp_us_national===true&&event.detail?.consent?.targeted_advertising_gpp_us_state===true&&event.detail?.consent?.marketing===true){delete Fides.fides_meta.converted_consent}});var fidesPrefix="fides_";var searchParams=new URLSearchParams(location.search);var fidesSearchParams=new URLSearchParams;searchParams.forEach(function(value,key){if(key.startsWith(fidesPrefix)){fidesSearchParams.set(key.replace(fidesPrefix,""),key===fidesPrefix+"cache_bust"?Date.now().toString():value)}});var src="https://privacy.advancelocal.com/fides.js?"+fidesSearchParams.toString();var script=document.createElement("script");script.setAttribute("src",src);document.head.appendChild(script)}();</script><script>
window.ddjskey = '1008AE3795DD2B2EA48B1645AD17E2';
window.ddoptions = {};
</script><script data-testid="script-adidata">window.adiData = {"affiliate":"cleveland","entryUrl":"https://www.cleveland.com/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html","environment":"prod","pageType":"cal","rgProduct":"cal","preview":false,"siteSection":"News","pvid":"9726cd00-6bdc-495f-acaa-37098eb5759a","entryTags":"@yyy;@lll;ohio-senate-race-2022;ohio-senate-race-2024","entryId":"TGEUPTW2X5GK3EGJZHV43ABBNY","blogCategory":"news","entryHeadline":"Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records","entryDescription":"This year, $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups. That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three Senate races combined.","entryAuthorUsername":"andrewjtobias","entryDateOriginal":"2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z","entryDateUpdated":"2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z","arcEntryId":"TGEUPTW2X5GK3EGJZHV43ABBNY","arcCategories":"Politics>Elections;Politics;Business and Finance;Sports;Sports>American Football;Business and Finance>Business;Politics>Civic affairs;Politics>Political Issues & policy;Events","arcCategoriesUid":"387;386;52;483;484;53;8YPBBL;388;8VZQHL","arcCategoriesTier1":"Politics;Business and Finance;Sports;Events","arcCategoriesLowestTier":"Politics>Elections;Business and Finance>Business;Sports>American Football;Politics>Civic affairs;Politics>Political Issues & policy;Events","arcSensitiveTopics":"No Sensitive Topics","arcCustomCategories":"","arcCustomCategoriesUid":"","arcComboCategories":"Politics>Elections;Politics;Business and Finance;Sports;Sports>American Football;Business and Finance>Business;Politics>Civic affairs;Politics>Political Issues & policy;Events","arcEntities":"Jim Renacci|Agent,Person,Politician,Congressman;Tim Ryan (Ohio politician)|Agent,Person,Politician;Josh Mandel|Agent,Person,Politician,OfficeHolder;J. D. Vance|Agent,Person,Politician;Sherrod Brown|Agent,Person,Politician;Joe Manchin|Agent,Person,Politician,OfficeHolder;Rob Portman|Agent,Person,Politician,President;Ted Strickland|Agent,Person,Politician,OfficeHolder;Save America|Agent,Organisation;The Plain Dealer|Work,WrittenWork,PeriodicalLiterature,Newspaper;Mitch McConnell|Agent,Person,Politician;Peter Thiel|Agent,Person;Republican Party (United States)|Agent,Organisation,PoliticalParty;Ohio|Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion;United States Senate|Agent,Organisation,Legislature;OpenSecrets|Agent,Organisation;Donald Trump|Agent,Person,Politician;Democratic Party (United States)|Agent,Organisation,PoliticalParty;Montana|Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion;California|Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion;West Virginia|Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion;United States House of Representatives|Agent,Organisation,Legislature","arcEntitiesUid":"Q976676;Q513960;Q6289137;Q28935729;Q381880;Q538868;Q926069;Q465295;Q113184095;Q286036;Q355522;Q705525;Q29468;Q1397;Q66096;Q2944364;Q22686;Q29552;Q1212;Q99;Q1371;Q11701","arcCustomEntities":"Tim Ryan|Agent,Person,Politician","arcCustomEntitiesUid":"ent0007","productBuyerPersonas":"","productIabBuyerPersonas":"","productCategories":"","entryDepth":"1"};
var environment = window.location.toString().includes("uat") ||
window.location.toString().includes("localhost") ? "uat" : "prod";
window.adiData.environment = environment;
</script><script type="text/javascript" id="react-google-tag-manager-gtm-head">
if (!window.dataLayer) {
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
}
window.dataLayer.push(window.adiData);
(function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];
w[l].push({'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js', });
var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';
j.async=true;j.src='https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl
;
f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f);
})(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-5FH8H3G');</script><script type="text/javascript">!(function(b,_name){b[_name]=b[_name]||function n(){(n.q=n.q||[]).push(arguments)},b[_name].v=b[_name].v||2,b[_name].s="3";!(function(b,n,v,U,Q){function V(U,Q){try{V=b.localStorage,(U=JSON.parse(V[decodeURI(decodeURI('g%25%36%35%74I%25%37%34%256%35%6d'))](v)).lgk||[])&&(Q=b[n].pubads())&&U.forEach((function(b){b&&b[0]&&Q.setTargeting(b[0],b[1]||"")}))}catch(q){}var V}try{(Q=b[n]=b[n]||{}).cmd=Q.cmd||[],typeof Q.pubads===U?V():typeof Q.cmd.unshift===U?Q.cmd.unshift(V):Q.cmd.push(V)}catch(q){}})(window,decodeURI(decodeURI('%25%36%37o%25%36%66%67l%2565%74a%256%37')),"_a"+decodeURI(decodeURI("%2551%25%35%33%25301%51%257%61lF%25%34%65%257%61%42%254%36%51%25%36b%25%351%253%35%52%254%34%256b%77%4e%54%49%25%33%31N%25%33%30%255%39%32M%25%36%61V%25%34%32%255%31U%25%349t%4d%2567")),"function");;})(window,decodeURI(decodeURI('a%256%34%25%36%64%256%39r%2561l')));!(function(b,n,v,U,Q,V,q,z,s,f,K,l,P,O,I,G,H,j,p,e,d,k,y,C,Z){function m(v,V){navigator.onLine&&e&&(e=!1,(V=(function(b,n,v){if(!G)return!1;for(n=(b=G.getEntriesByType("resource")).length;v=b[--n];)if(!v.deliveryType&&v.transferSize>300&&v.fetchStart>H)return!0;return!1})())||(Z=8),!d&&p&&(Z=16),!d&&!V||(function(v,V,q){if(!/bot|spider|headlesschrome|java\//i.test(navigator.userAgent||"")&&(new(function(){v=(function h(e,t,r,n){if(!e||(function e(r,n,i,o){for(o=0;r&&o<r.length;o+=2)o>0&&(r[o+1]||[]).unshift(i),i=(n=t[r[o]])&&n(e,r[o+1]||[]);return i})(e))return r.apply(this,n||[])}([0,[[[1,[[3,[],2,["/digitalsubscription"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,["/insider"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,["/subscribe"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,["/supporter"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,["/contributor"]]]],[4,[[[1,[[6,["%25%361%64%256%64%2562%25%365%256%65%2565%25%36%36%69t%25%373"],5,[""]]]]]]],[1,[[6,["%25%363a%6c%25%36%35%255%66r%65%2573%25%375%6c%74%257%33"],5,["true"]]]]]]],[function c(e,t){for(var r=t[0]&&t[0].length>0,n=0;r&&n<t[0].length;n++)r=e(t[0][n]);return r},function a(e,t){return!e(t[0])},function l(e,t,r,n){return r=t[0]||"",(n=t[1]||"")?0===r.indexOf(n):!!r},function p(e,t,r){return"/"+(document.location.pathname||"").replace(/^\/+|\/+$/,"")},function c(e,t){for(var r=t[0]&&t[0].length>0,n=0;r&&n<t[0].length;n++)r=e(t[0][n]);return r},function u(e,t,r,n){return r=t[0]||"",(n=t[1]||"")?-1!==r.indexOf(n):!!r},function f(e,t,r){return(r=(document.cookie||"").match(new RegExp("(^|;\\s*)"+decodeURI(decodeURI(t[0]))+"\\s*=\\s*([^;]+)")))?r[2]:void 0}],function(d,c,e,f,i,m,y){e=d.createElement("div");e.innerHTML="<div class=\"DCDOr\"><div class=\"eRIqgq a__s1p0xe8r-0\"><div class=\"ezkXGa a__s1p0xe8r-0\"><div class=\"fkhZMO\"><h3 class=\"kMGqeO\">Your experience is important to us.<\/h3><div class=\"eFEjHN\">For optimal functionality on cleveland.com, please disable your ad blocker before continuing.\n<div id=\"admLoginLink\" style=\"position:relative;top:86px;\"><a href=\"https://auth0.cleveland.com/u/login?adm_src=admiral\" style=\"color:#333333;text-decoration:underline;font-size:12px;font-weight: bold;font-family: Helvetica;\">Already a Subscriber? Log In<\/a><\/div><\/div><button data-5mfku-0 data-s9pexq4cgx=\"https://my.g%65%74adm%69r%61l.com/instructions\" class=\"ilwEwD a__s1p0xe8r-1\">Disable my adblocker<\/button><\/div><div class=\"jozuUb\"><img src=\"https://i.imgur.com/4hqNGzW.png\" class=\"hgqALM\"><\/img><\/div><\/div><\/div><div class=\"idHFrh\"><span class=\"bRORkN\"><a href=\"https://%67e%74%61dmira%6c.typeform.com/to/s8M2nY5H\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"dWdYmI\">Contact support<\/a><\/span><span class=\"bRORkN\">|<\/span><span class=\"bRORkN\"><a href=\"https://g%65%74%61%64%6d%69%72%61l.com/pb/\" target=\"_blank\" class=\"dWdYmI\">We're using <img src=\"https://pubimgs.net/412d3543394537304542443944393035323537463632354141422d32_logo.svg\" class=\"ggJJaU\"><\/img><\/a><\/span><\/div><\/div>";f=["click",function(e){var t=e.currentTarget.getAttribute("data-s9pexq4cgx"),r=e.currentTarget.parentElement,n=document.createElement("iframe");n.src=t,n.style="margin: 36px 0;outline: 0;border: 0;width: 100%;height: 400px;",r.replaceWith(n);var i=function(e){var t=e.data,o=t.goBack,c=t.blockerDisabled;o?(n.replaceWith(r),window.removeEventListener("message",i)):c&&window.location.reload()};window.addEventListener("message",i)}];for (i=0;i<f.length;i+=2){(m=e.querySelector('[data-5mfku-'+i+']'))&&m.addEventListener(f[i],f[i+1])}y=d.createElement("style");y[c](d.createTextNode(".DCDOr{all:initial;position:fixed;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;left:0;font-family:Arial;overflow:auto;background-color:rgba(255,255,255,1);z-index:2147483647;}.DCDOr .a__s1p0xe8r-0{width:100%;height:100%;margin:0 auto;}.DCDOr .a__s1p0xe8r-1{cursor:pointer;border:none;font-weight:700;}.eRIqgq{max-width:740px;position:relative;}.ezkXGa{box-sizing:border-box;display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-flex-direction:column;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;-webkit-align-items:flex-start;-webkit-box-align:flex-start;-ms-flex-align:flex-start;align-items:flex-start;-webkit-box-pack:center;-webkit-justify-content:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;}.fkhZMO{display:inline-block;max-width:700px;width:100%;margin-bottom:48px;padding-bottom:48px;border-bottom:1px solid #121e401f;color:rgba(24,33,57,1);}.idHFrh{position:fixed;bottom:0;height:40px;width:100%;text-align:center;line-height:40px;font-size:13px;color:rgba(12,44,91,1);background-color:rgba(24,33,57,0.05);}.jozuUb{display:block;}.hgqALM{max-width:150px;max-height:150px;}.ggJJaU{height:15px;vertical-align:middle;}.kMGqeO{box-sizing:border-box;text-align:left;margin:0 0 5px;font-size:24px;line-height:28px;font-weight:500;}.eFEjHN{box-sizing:border-box;text-align:left;margin:0 0 15px;font-size:14px;line-height:22px;}.bRORkN{display:inline-block;margin-right:5px;line-height:40px;}.dWdYmI{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;color:rgba(12,44,91,1);}.ilwEwD{width:100%;height:33px;background-color:rgba(42,42,42,1);color:rgba(244,244,246,1);border-radius:3px;margin-bottom:24px;}"));d.body[c](y);d.body[c](e);window[decodeURI(decodeURI('%25%35fa%2564m%255%33%74%25%361%74%2569cEn%25%36%37%2561%2567e%25%35%32%65%6e%64%2565r%65%25%36%34'))]=!0;return {"candidates":[{"batchID":"659c6815ef8207d1326e80f3","candidateID":"659c6815ef8207d1326e80f2","groups":["purpose:failsafe"],"payload":{"name":"Failsafe"},"payloadType":"template","simpleCriteria":{},"triggers":[{"type":"adblockerDisabled"}],"tsUpdated":1749138818.239}]}},[document,"appendChild"]))}),!f++)){V=n.sessionStorage;try{q=JSON.parse(V[U(U(K))]).slice(-4)}catch(z){q=[]}q.push([Q(),{p:""+n.location,r:""+b.referrer,cs:v,t:1,fc:Z}]),V[U(U(K))]=JSON.stringify(q)}})())}G=n.performance,p=n.fetch,P=U(U('%256%31d%256%64%25%36%39%25%37%32%25%361%25%36c')),O=U(U('%25%361dm%257%32%256cLoa%64%25%36%35%2564')),e=!p,(function o(U,V,f,K,y,C){function Z(){n[O]&&v(I),C||n[P]&&n[P].a&&"function"==typeof n[P].a.ready||u()}function u(b){f&&y.removeChild(f),v(I),b&&!1===b.isTrusted||V>=4?(n.setTimeout(m,d!==undefined||e?0:Math.max(4e3-(Q()-j),Math.max(2e3-((G&&G.now())-H),0))),e=!0):o(V<2?U:l,++V)}(C=U===l)&&3===V&&p(U).then((function(b){b.ok?b.text().then((function(b){b.includes(O)?v(I):u({})}),(function(b){u({})})):u({})}),(function(b){u({})})),f=b.createElement(q),K=b[s](q)[0],y=K.parentNode,f.async=1,f.src=U,1==V&&p&&(j=Q(),p((function(v,U,Q,V,q,z,f,K){for(U=(v=b[s]("link")).length,V=(n.origin||"").length||1;V&&(Q=v[--U]);)if(q=(Q.href||"").substring(0,V),f=0===(Q.type||"").indexOf("image/"),K="icon"===Q.rel||(Q.rel||"").indexOf(" icon")>=0,(f||K)&&("/"===q[0]||q===n.origin)&&(z=Q.href,f&&K))return Q.href;return z||"/favicon.ico"})(),{mode:"no-cors",credentials:"omit",cache:"no-cache"}).then((function(){d=!0,m()}),(function(b){d=!1}))),k=0,1===V&&k?k(f,(function(b){b||Z()})):f[z]&&(I=n.setTimeout(Z,C?3e4:6e3),f[z]("error",u),f[z]("load",Z)),y.insertBefore(f,K)})("https://cardmethod.com/build/jecdpirqtjtz.index.js",0),H=G&&G.now()})(document,window,clearTimeout,decodeURI,Date.now,0,"script","addEventListener","getElementsByTagName",0,'%256%31%66sv%256%39s%25%369t%2573',"https://succeedscene.com/customads/custom_ads.js");</script><script type="text/javascript">if(window?.admiral){window.admiral("targeting","pause");}</script>
<script>(window.BOOMR_mq=window.BOOMR_mq||[]).push(["addVar",{"rua.upush":"false","rua.cpush":"false","rua.upre":"false","rua.cpre":"false","rua.uprl":"false","rua.cprl":"false","rua.cprf":"false","rua.trans":"","rua.cook":"false","rua.ims":"false","rua.ufprl":"false","rua.cfprl":"false","rua.isuxp":"false","rua.texp":"norulematch","rua.ceh":"false","rua.ueh":"false","rua.ieh.st":"0"}]);</script>
<script>!function(e){var n="https://s.go-mpulse.net/boomerang/";if("False"=="True")e.BOOMR_config=e.BOOMR_config||{},e.BOOMR_config.PageParams=e.BOOMR_config.PageParams||{},e.BOOMR_config.PageParams.pci=!0,n="https://s2.go-mpulse.net/boomerang/";if(window.BOOMR_API_key="ULCF4-RBZRV-4JZ28-8X7RY-3TNU9",function(){function e(){if(!o){var e=document.createElement("script");e.id="boomr-scr-as",e.src=window.BOOMR.url,e.async=!0,i.parentNode.appendChild(e),o=!0}}function t(e){o=!0;var n,t,a,r,d=document,O=window;if(window.BOOMR.snippetMethod=e?"if":"i",t=function(e,n){var t=d.createElement("script");t.id=n||"boomr-if-as",t.src=window.BOOMR.url,BOOMR_lstart=(new Date).getTime(),e=e||d.body,e.appendChild(t)},!window.addEventListener&&window.attachEvent&&navigator.userAgent.match(/MSIE [67]\./))return window.BOOMR.snippetMethod="s",void t(i.parentNode,"boomr-async");a=document.createElement("IFRAME"),a.src="about:blank",a.title="",a.role="presentation",a.loading="eager",r=(a.frameElement||a).style,r.width=0,r.height=0,r.border=0,r.display="none",i.parentNode.appendChild(a);try{O=a.contentWindow,d=O.document.open()}catch(_){n=document.domain,a.src="javascript:var d=document.open();d.domain='"+n+"';void(0);",O=a.contentWindow,d=O.document.open()}if(n)d._boomrl=function(){this.domain=n,t()},d.write("<bo"+"dy onload='document._boomrl();'>");else if(O._boomrl=function(){t()},O.addEventListener)O.addEventListener("load",O._boomrl,!1);else if(O.attachEvent)O.attachEvent("onload",O._boomrl);d.close()}function a(e){window.BOOMR_onload=e&&e.timeStamp||(new Date).getTime()}if(!window.BOOMR||!window.BOOMR.version&&!window.BOOMR.snippetExecuted){window.BOOMR=window.BOOMR||{},window.BOOMR.snippetStart=(new Date).getTime(),window.BOOMR.snippetExecuted=!0,window.BOOMR.snippetVersion=12,window.BOOMR.url=n+"ULCF4-RBZRV-4JZ28-8X7RY-3TNU9";var i=document.currentScript||document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0],o=!1,r=document.createElement("link");if(r.relList&&"function"==typeof r.relList.supports&&r.relList.supports("preload")&&"as"in r)window.BOOMR.snippetMethod="p",r.href=window.BOOMR.url,r.rel="preload",r.as="script",r.addEventListener("load",e),r.addEventListener("error",function(){t(!0)}),setTimeout(function(){if(!o)t(!0)},3e3),BOOMR_lstart=(new Date).getTime(),i.parentNode.appendChild(r);else t(!1);if(window.addEventListener)window.addEventListener("load",a,!1);else if(window.attachEvent)window.attachEvent("onload",a)}}(),"".length>0)if(e&&"performance"in e&&e.performance&&"function"==typeof e.performance.setResourceTimingBufferSize)e.performance.setResourceTimingBufferSize();!function(){if(BOOMR=e.BOOMR||{},BOOMR.plugins=BOOMR.plugins||{},!BOOMR.plugins.AK){var n=""=="true"?1:0,t="",a="z7y62yyxbphy42kdznga-f-e3e1ee199-clientnsv4-s.akamaihd.net",i="false"=="true"?2:1,o={"ak.v":"39","ak.cp":"719750","ak.ai":parseInt("468254",10),"ak.ol":"0","ak.cr":3,"ak.ipv":4,"ak.proto":"http/1.1","ak.rid":"50c413c1","ak.r":53120,"ak.a2":n,"ak.m":"dscr","ak.n":"ff","ak.bpcip":"207.241.237.0","ak.cport":33424,"ak.gh":"2.22.28.11","ak.quicv":"","ak.tlsv":"tls1.3","ak.0rtt":"","ak.0rtt.ed":"","ak.csrc":"-","ak.acc":"bbr","ak.t":"1766050636","ak.ak":"hOBiQwZUYzCg5VSAfCLimQ==FQCpPuLzb+KQgEkzRPo5c3vy6j+gl1eN2rsDwMuOkW16pu6CjtlhGHnqTM6KhwxeqoBzHEQk0S1jpDojWVzaEPqGaacCBhO8LEPnwz27wmld98sZ4CC2Z/kwf4rzUfogGsBPwEJvqcqy+kWVoUQpJmlxfG2EKK8cQd0OaAO4dmwQqx71aJXQsKoTh5l+k3DBBQdm4eDuHCZprMwUAeLQbv/DtRTNHQ8rFB5X2/A18PAVDjCVL3qF8ZOPmt9ET7bKd6Ztg6N/oHMFCBZ7mUN05wAtA3eBAZ0si2j0iH/ONHuHhY17eq3mnVhzL1TKv89uvkg23qwyvkXdW1t5X+dsdKNYE8RNK5AjRZ2oY2NjUZtItdzn9/zBhr++MSuZqYcvIYOf6V05E5GShxjQIJDKHykppi+BNe4fal9LbpegVLs=","ak.pv":"69","ak.dpoabenc":"","ak.tf":i};if(""!==t)o["ak.ruds"]=t;var r={i:!1,av:function(n){var t="http.initiator";if(n&&(!n[t]||"spa_hard"===n[t]))o["ak.feo"]=void 0!==e.aFeoApplied?1:0,BOOMR.addVar(o)},rv:function(){var e=["ak.bpcip","ak.cport","ak.cr","ak.csrc","ak.gh","ak.ipv","ak.m","ak.n","ak.ol","ak.proto","ak.quicv","ak.tlsv","ak.0rtt","ak.0rtt.ed","ak.r","ak.acc","ak.t","ak.tf"];BOOMR.removeVar(e)}};BOOMR.plugins.AK={akVars:o,akDNSPreFetchDomain:a,init:function(){if(!r.i){var e=BOOMR.subscribe;e("before_beacon",r.av,null,null),e("onbeacon",r.rv,null,null),r.i=!0}return this},is_complete:function(){return!0}}}}()}(window);</script></head><body class="body__cleveland page-type__article" data-affiliate="cleveland" data-page-type="article"><div id="fusion-app"><div class="skipTo"><a class="skipTo__link" href="#main">Skip to Article</a></div><div class="toprail"><div id="toprailContainer"><div class="toprail" id="toprail"><header class="advtoprail"><div class="advtoprail__left-corner "><div class="advtoprail__hamburgerWrapper"></div><div class="advtoprail__weather"><button class="advtoprail__button advtoprail__weather-button " aria-label="Set Your Local Weather Forecast" aria-expanded="false"><span class="advtoprail__weather-conditions"><span class="advtoprail__weather-temperature ">Set weather</span></span><svg width="16" height="16" viewBox="0 0 64 64" fill="none" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M11.3339 27.3171C12.1224 26.4406 13.4186 26.4406 14.2037 27.3171L32 45.6161L49.7963 27.3171C50.5814 26.4406 51.8776 26.4406 52.6661 27.3171C53.4546 28.1936 53.4546 29.5923 52.6661 30.4688L35.1661 48.5082C33.5912 50.1639 30.4088 50.1639 28.8339 48.5082L11.3339 30.4688C10.5454 29.5923 10.5454 28.1936 11.3339 27.3171Z" fill="#FFFFFF"></path></svg></button><div class="advtoprail__dropdown advtoprail__dropdown--weather " aria-hidden="true"><div class="advtoprail__menuborderarrow advtoprail__menuborderarrow--weather"></div><div class="advtoprail__dropdown-outer"><div class="advtoprail__dropdown-inner--weather"><button class="advtoprail__button advtoprail__button-mobile-backtomain"><span class="advtoprail__button-icon--backmm"></span><span class="advtoprail__button-label--backmm">Back To Main Menu</span></button><button class="advtoprail__button advtoprail__button--close" aria-label="Close the Find Your Weather Forecast popup"><span class="advtoprail__button-icon advtoprail__button-icon--close"></span><span class="advtoprail__iconlabel">Close</span></button><div class="advtoprail__weather-details"><div class="advtoprail__weather-subtitle">Quick Look</div><div class="advtoprail__weather-title">-</div><button class="advtoprail__weather-button--change-location">Change your current location »</button><div class="advtoprail__weather-forecast"><div class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-period"><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-label">Current</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-icon"><img src="/pf/resources/images/common/weather/small/02.png?d=1703" alt="Mostly Sunny" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-highlow"></span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-temperature"> <!-- -->-</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-condition">Mostly Sunny</span></div><div class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-period"><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-label">Tonight</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-icon"><img src="/pf/resources/images/common/weather/small/02.png?d=1703" alt="Mostly Sunny" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-highlow">Low</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-temperature"> <!-- -->-</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-condition">Mostly Sunny</span></div><div class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-period"><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-label">Tomorrow</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-icon"><img src="/pf/resources/images/common/weather/small/02.png?d=1703" alt="Mostly Sunny" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-highlow">High</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-temperature"> <!-- -->-</span><span class="advtoprail__weather-forecast-condition">Mostly Sunny</span></div></div><button id="" class="ds-button ds-button--primary ds-button--large " aria-label="View full weather report"><span>View full weather report</span></button></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="advtoprail__masthead"><div class="advtoprail__masthead-logo"><a class="advtoprail__masthead-afflink" href="https://www.cleveland.com" aria-label="Visit the cleveland.com covering northeast Ohio homepage"><img class="advtoprail__masthead-afflink-logo" src="https://www.cleveland.com/pf/resources/images/cleveland/logos/logo_main_inverse.svg?d=1703" alt="cleveland’s Logo" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/><img class="advtoprail__masthead-afflink-logo-sm" src="https://www.cleveland.com/pf/resources/images/cleveland/logos/logo_main_sm.svg?d=1703" alt="cleveland’s Logo" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></a></div></div><div class="advtoprail__right-corner"><div class="advToprail__right-corner--subscribe"></div><div class="advtoprail__authWrapper"><div></div></div></div></header></div></div><div class="alert-bar alert-bar--news-promo"><div class="alert-bar__text"><div class="alert-bar__headline"><a class="alert-bar__headline-link alert-bar__headline-link--news-promo" href="https://www.cleveland.com/digitalsubscription/inline/">Family Sharing is here! Subscribe to Premium Access for $5</a></div></div></div></div><div id="below-toprail" class="below-toprail"></div><main id="main" class="main-wrapper--article"><div class="article__header header"><nav class="articleLabel" aria-label="articleLabel"><ol id="articleLabel__list" class="articleLabel__list"><li id="articleLabel__listItem" class="articleLabel__listItem"><a id="articleLabel__link" class="articleLabel__link" href="/news/" title="Navigate to News">News</a></li></ol></nav><div class="headline-basic headline-basic__article"><h1 class="Heading-module_heading__76MAI Heading-module_notoserif__BL0Ec Heading-module_size40__4IMQF Heading-module_semibold__e9hKa Heading-module_primary__eJSqP Heading-module_normal__gW3V8 ">Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records</h1></div><ul class="dateline"><li class="dateline__published"><time dateTime="2023-01-05167291280100010:00:01">Published: <!-- -->Jan. 05, 2023, 10:00 a.m.</time></li></ul></div><div class="main article__story " aria-live="polite"><article id="arc-TGEUPTW2X5GK3EGJZHV43ABBNY" class="article h-entry" data-type="article"><div class="multimedia-main"><figure class="article__image"><div class="article__image-wrapper"><img fetchPriority="high" loading="eager" decoding="sync" alt="Tim Ryan JD Vance" class="hero-image" src="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90" srcSet="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=500&smart=true&quality=90 500w, https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=800&smart=true&quality=90 800w, https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90 1280w" sizes="(max-width: 500px) 100vw, (max-width: 800px) 80vw, 60vw"/><figcaption class="article__image-caption"><span class="article__mm-image-caption-text">This combination of photos shows Ohio Democratic Senate candidate Rep. Tim Ryan, D-Ohio, on March 28, 2022, in Wilberforce, Ohio, left, and Republican candidate JD Vance on Aug. 5, 2022, in Dallas. (AP Photo)<span class="article__mm-image-credit">AP</span></span></figcaption></div></figure></div><div class="sharebarBetaWrapper"><div class="sharebarBeta-container"><div class="sharebarBeta"><ul><li><button class="sharebarButton cleveland" aria-label="Share on Facebook"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xml:space="preserve" style="enable-background:new 0 0 64 64" viewBox="0 0 64 64" width="24" height="24" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path d="M60 32.169c0-15.462-12.537-28-28-28s-28 12.538-28 28C4 46.144 14.238 57.728 27.625 59.83V40.265h-7.111v-8.096h7.111V26c0-7.016 4.181-10.895 10.576-10.895 3.064 0 6.269.547 6.269.547v6.891h-3.532c-3.476 0-4.564 2.157-4.564 4.375v5.25h7.765l-1.24 8.096h-6.524v19.568C49.763 57.731 60 46.147 60 32.169z" fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" fill="#2A2A2A"></path></svg></button></li><li><button class="sharebarButton cleveland" aria-label="Bookmark this article" disabled=""><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xml:space="preserve" style="enable-background:new 0 0 64 64" viewBox="0 0 64 64" width="24" height="24" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path d="M38 10H20C18.9391 10 17.922 10.4217 17.1719 11.1719C16.4217 11.922 16 12.9391 16 14V55.5449L30.6709 42.5049C31.4287 41.8313 32.5713 41.8313 33.3291 42.5049L48 55.5449V20H52V60C52 60.7875 51.5377 61.5016 50.8193 61.8242C50.1009 62.1469 49.2595 62.0184 48.6709 61.4951L32 46.6758L15.3291 61.4951C14.7405 62.0184 13.8991 62.1469 13.1807 61.8242C12.4623 61.5016 12 60.7875 12 60V14C12 11.8783 12.8425 9.84306 14.3428 8.34277C15.8431 6.84248 17.8783 6 20 6H38V10Z" fill="#2A2A2A"></path><line x1="50" y1="4" x2="50" y2="12" stroke="#2A2A2A" stroke-width="4" stroke-linecap="square" stroke-linejoin="round"></line><line x1="54" y1="8" x2="46" y2="8" stroke="#2A2A2A" stroke-width="4" stroke-linecap="square" stroke-linejoin="round"></line></svg></button></li><li><button class="sharebarButton cleveland" aria-label="View bookmarked articles"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xml:space="preserve" style="enable-background:new 0 0 64 64" viewBox="0 0 64 64" width="24" height="24" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path d="M16,10V8c0.01-3.31,2.69-5.99,6-6h28c3.31,0.01,5.99,2.69,6,6v46l-10-8" fill="none" stroke="#2A2A2A" stroke-width="4" stroke-linejoin="round"></path><path d="M40,12H14c-3.31,0.01-5.99,2.69-6,6v44l19-16l19,16V18C45.99,14.69,43.31,12.01,40,12z" fill="none" stroke="#2A2A2A" stroke-width="4" stroke-linejoin="round"></path></svg></button></li></ul></div><div class="sharebarBeta-gifting-modal-container"></div></div></div><div class="byline"><span>By </span><ul class="byline__authorList"><li class="byline__author"><a class="byline__authorLink" href="https://www.cleveland.com/staff/andrewjtobias/" title="Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com">Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com</a></li></ul></div><div class="entry-content "><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="GGDKIHGEONBOPDV3B4JOQL7HP4">COLUMBUS, Ohio – Candidates, their affiliates and outside political groups spent almost as much on the 2022 U.S. Senate race in Ohio than in the previous three elections combined, according to campaign finance data.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-1" data-gaid="inarticle-1"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="U2OSTR7CE5EA3JIAFULKJMQLQE">The massive spending on last year’s race was fueled by r<a href="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2022/10/tim-ryan-outraises-jd-vance-blowing-out-state-record-in-final-pre-election-fundraising-period-for-ohios-us-senate-race.html" target="_blank">ecord-busting personal fundraising by the Democratic nominee</a>, a big tech <a href="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2022/07/super-pac-discloses-raising-spending-millions-helping-jd-vance-win-ohios-us-senate-republican-primary.html" target="_blank">cash infusion in the GOP primary</a> for the eventual Republican candidate and millions of dollars spent by outside groups. About $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race last year, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups, according to a cleveland.com/Plain Dealer review of federal campaign finance data.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-2" data-gaid="inarticle-2"></div><div class="excoVideoPlayer article__paragraph"><div id="d3b24dcf-0d0d-41c4-a341-f607f5b1d9e3" data-exs-config=""></div></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="AINOMKQUXRBBRJMQ6H7GBQWLY4">That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three races combined, according to data compiled by the nonpartisan <a href="http://opensecrets.org/" target="_blank">OpenSecrets.org</a> – $37.7 million for the 2018 race, in which Sen. Sherrod Brown won reelection over Republican Jim Renacci; $91 million on the 2016 Senate race, in which Republican Sen. Rob Portman defeated Democratic former governor Ted Strickland; and $82.3 million in 2012, when Brown defeated Republican Josh Mandel.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-3" data-gaid="inarticle-3"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="F3L45TWF35COFF4OBTRRWWI5Q4">Last year’s race pitted Tim Ryan, a Democratic congressman from the Youngstown area, against J.D. Vance, a Republican investor/author from Cincinnati, to replace retiring GOP Sen. Rob Portman. Vance won the November election by 6 percentage points, a comfortable win but relatively competitive compared to the rest of Ohio’s statewide elections, which Republican candidates otherwise won by double digits.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-4" data-gaid="inarticle-4"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="P7L2UEB525HMDIL6KRNXEBAD3M">In addition to the general election, which drew heavy spending, the Republican primary election also was hotly competitive, since it presented a rare opportunity to run for an open seat in a Republican-leaning state. Vance ultimately won, defeating four well-funded opponents. The Democratic primary, in which Ryan easily defeated two opponents, was much less competitive and saw much less spending.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-5" data-gaid="inarticle-5"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="MU5A65NLPFDBJBVFGZK4SGOFQM">The ballooning cash spent on the 2022 Senate race could be a harbinger of things to come. Control of the U.S. Senate, in which Democrats hold a slim majority, will be up or grabs again in 2024. The Senate map that year is expected to favor Republicans, with three incumbent Democrats – Ohio’s Brown, plus Sen. John Tester of Montana and Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia – running for reelection in states that ex-President Donald Trump won in 2020.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-6" data-gaid="inarticle-6"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="EG3DEVHIUFDHNIEW2OMUDE3HWY">Trump won Ohio by 8 percentage points in 2020, compared to his 17-point win in Montana and his 39-point victory in West Virginia, which means Ohio’s U.S. Senate race likely will be a top priority for both national Democrats and Republicans.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-7" data-gaid="inarticle-7"></div><h1 class="article-heading"><b>Breaking down spending in this year’s race</b></h1><div id="inarticle-8" data-gaid="inarticle-8"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="C3QU5YYVQBFGRN6X5OBMHFKGX4">A majority of the spending from official candidate committees in last year’s Senate race was due to Ryan’s prolific fundraising.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-9" data-gaid="inarticle-9"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="2WY2HOOMBNASDIRRLZKYDK5UBM">Ryan and an affiliated committee spent $60.7 million, nearly two-thirds of the $93.9 million raised by all campaigns and their affiliates, and compared to the nearly $18.5 million spent by Vance and an affiliate.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-10" data-gaid="inarticle-10"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="5P4PGJ25LZAB3KWAJAKZTF76KM">The $53.4 million raised directly by Ryan’s campaign was a record, almost double the previous record of $28.7 million set by Brown in 2018.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-11" data-gaid="inarticle-11"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="J6CMDARPSFFKNC3XVLMSA47WI4">As we’ve previously reported, a unique dynamic of the race was the large amounts of personal money Republican candidates’ spent on their campaigns. In all, Republicans candidates loaned themselves $30.5 million. Most of that, $18.1 million, is the money Mike Gibbons, a Cleveland businessman, lost while unsuccessfully running in the Republican primary election. Vance loaned his campaign $1.4 million, while Ryan did not loan his campaign any money.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-12" data-gaid="inarticle-12"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="YNXRKEG6GREYLAFLOTVXEKJKFA">Here’s a table breaking down the candidate-by-candidate campaign-finance data. Note, the topline spending exceeds fundraising because it doesn’t include personal candidate loans and affiliated committee transfers, among other quirks in how federal campaign finance data is recorded.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-13" class="middleParagraph" data-gaid="inarticle-13"></div><div id="fusion-static-enter:N6UBWTCJMRBPDGZYUF7DQ2LQ64" style="display:none" data-fusion-component="N6UBWTCJMRBPDGZYUF7DQ2LQ64"></div><div class="rawhtml"><style type="text/css">
table.tableizer-table {
font-size: 12px;
border: 1px solid #CCC;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
}
.tableizer-table td {
padding: 4px;
margin: 3px;
border: 1px solid #CCC;
}
.tableizer-table th {
background-color: #104E8B;
color: #FFF;
font-weight: bold;
}
</style>
<table class="tableizer-table">
<thead><tr class="tableizer-firstrow"><th>Committee</th><th>Amount raised</th><th>Amount Spent</th><th>Candidate loans</th><th>Party</th></tr></thead><tbody>
<tr><td>Tim Ryan for Ohio</td><td>$53,399,343</td><td>$55,293,286</td><td>$0</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>
<tr><td>J.D. Vance for Senate</td><td>$11,048,086</td><td>$13,980,514</td><td>$1,400,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Gibbons for Ohio</td><td>$19,308,077</td><td>$19,281,487</td><td>$18,170,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Dolan for Ohio</td><td>$11,294,797</td><td>$11,200,399</td><td>$2,607,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Timken for Ohio</td><td>$8,706,571</td><td>$8,698,358</td><td>$4,060,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Bernie Moreno for Ohio</td><td>$6,860,887</td><td>$6,860,522</td><td>$3,806,142</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Citizens for Josh Mandel</td><td>$3,266,385</td><td>$7,627,693</td><td>$0</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Morgan Harper for Ohio</td><td>$1,318,601</td><td>$1,306,245</td><td>$0</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>
<tr><td>Mark Pukita for US Senate</td><td>$504,103</td><td>$898,426</td><td>$461,143</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>TOTALS</td><td>$83,755,505</td><td>$125,146,930</td><td>$30,504,285</td><td></td></tr>
</tbody></table></div><div id="fusion-static-exit:N6UBWTCJMRBPDGZYUF7DQ2LQ64" style="display:none" data-fusion-component="N6UBWTCJMRBPDGZYUF7DQ2LQ64"></div><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-14" data-gaid="inarticle-14"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="IL55XKHGCZG2HIH5WYVLUO3CL4">But Republican groups made up the lion’s share of the $103.7 million that outside groups spent in Ohio. The largest outside spender was the Senate Leadership Fund, which is closely aligned with Republican U.S. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell. Along with a nonprofit affiliate, the McConnell-backed groups spent $36.2 million helping Vance win the race. Another pro-Vance group, the Protect Ohio Values Super PAC, spent $19.5 million helping Vance. A single donor, California billionaire Peter Thiel, who is Vance’s former boss, was the group’s largest funder, giving it $15 million.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-15" data-gaid="inarticle-15"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="KOUB6OSLSRBUPC6TIRVUHJ3POY">In comparison, outside Democratic groups spent around $14.1 million on the race. The two largest ones were the Save America Fund, a semi-official pro-Ryan PAC that spent $8 million helping Ryan and attacking Vance, and $2.8 million spent by the Future Forward PAC, a national progressive PAC that spent $2.8 million on anti-Vance attack ads.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-16" data-gaid="inarticle-16"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="ECY7LIMIRNGPZGBUEOJNWUGXTY">Here’s a table breaking down spending by outside groups. The data’s source is OpenSecrets.org.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-17" data-gaid="inarticle-17"></div><div id="fusion-static-enter:KMECZKYUQVC27OYYQCFPXUGJIQ" style="display:none" data-fusion-component="KMECZKYUQVC27OYYQCFPXUGJIQ"></div><div class="rawhtml"><style type="text/css">
table.tableizer-table {
font-size: 12px;
border: 1px solid #CCC;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
}
.tableizer-table td {
padding: 4px;
margin: 3px;
border: 1px solid #CCC;
}
.tableizer-table th {
background-color: #104E8B;
color: #FFF;
font-weight: bold;
}
</style>
<table class="tableizer-table">
<thead><tr class="tableizer-firstrow"><th>Outside groups</th><th>Amount spent</th><th>Affiliation</th><th>Party</th></tr></thead><tbody>
<tr><td>Senate Leadershp Fund</td><td>$32,465,089.00</td><td>pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Protect Ohio Values</td><td>$19,478,331.58</td><td>pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Club for Growth Action</td><td>$8,178,324.00</td><td>pro-Josh Mandel</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Save America Fund</td><td>$8,001,724.84</td><td>Pro-Tim Ryan</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>
<tr><td>USA Freedom Fund</td><td>$5,469,032.00</td><td>pro-Josh Mandel</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>One Nation</td><td>$3,800,000.00</td><td>Pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Ohio Leads PAC</td><td>$3,394,454.00</td><td>pro-Jane Timken</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Buckeye Leadership Fund</td><td>$2,933,163.00</td><td>pro-Matt Dolan</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Future Forward PAC</td><td>$2,868,040.95</td><td>Pro-Tim Ryan</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>
<tr><td>Make America Great Again</td><td>$2,398,187.00</td><td>Pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>Republican Accountability Project</td><td>$2,270,384.00</td><td>pro-Tim Ryan</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>
<tr><td>WFW Action Fund</td><td>$2,018,636.00</td><td>pro-Jane Timken</td><td>Republican</td></tr>
<tr><td>All remaining groups</td><td>$10,385,129.00</td><td> </td><td> </td></tr>
<tr><td>OUTSIDE GROUP TOTAL</td><td>$103,660,495.37</td><td> </td><td></td></tr>
</tbody></table></div><div id="fusion-static-exit:KMECZKYUQVC27OYYQCFPXUGJIQ" style="display:none" data-fusion-component="KMECZKYUQVC27OYYQCFPXUGJIQ"></div><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-18" data-gaid="inarticle-18"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="3R4DOWOHXBFQDOV33GN5V3RVYM">Campaign spending was a hot topic for both candidates last year. Vance frequently complained about Ryan’s large national donor base, which he said was evidence of his popularity with elite coastal Democrats. Republicans, meanwhile, privately groused about Vance’s poor fundraising.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-19" data-gaid="inarticle-19"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="RYAIGIQN6RAI3ANC34COHU26LU">Vance also said, as a first-time candidate, he was surprised how much political advertising matters, since it’s often the primary source of information voters get about candidates.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-20" data-gaid="inarticle-20"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="IVN63NEJVZC3DDHW5RSV4RK5EM">“I’ve run into a political opponent who’s very hot in the Acela Corridor,” Vance said, referring to the rail line that runs from Washington, D.C., to Boston, during an October speech at a conservative policy conference in Steubenville. “And $30 million has poured into the race. I’m not kidding.”</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-21" data-gaid="inarticle-21"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="JL7DP7I26NE3LGD4KJP7SKT55I">Ryan, meanwhile, frequently said Vance had “two donors”: McConnell and Thiel. As the November election neared, and as national Democrats passed on a major investment in the race, prioritizing races they deemed to be more winnable, Ryan also cast his campaign as lacking in resources, despite his huge individual fundraising advantage.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-22" data-gaid="inarticle-22"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="SWZIPALYYVAPHLPZTMJYF74E3U"><a href="https://youtu.be/HEedrQ7j6qc" target="_blank">During a post-election appearance at a conference for centrist Democrats in Washington, D.C.</a>, Ryan complained that national Democrats left him on the field. Another $10 million, he said, would have helped fund a better ground game that could have countered the <a href="https://www.cleveland.com/news/2022/10/early-voting-data-in-ohio-showing-signs-of-lagging-turnout-in-urban-areas.html" target="_blank">lower turnout in urban areas</a> that hurt Ryan and other Ohio Democrats.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-23" data-gaid="inarticle-23"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="4UJYFUPHR5C5PHERTVOWRBBOCM">That left his campaign to cover costs, like negative advertising, that typically would be picked up by outside groups.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-24" data-gaid="inarticle-24"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="6Z7YVTFQLZH77PN7IU562QT6TI">“Our problem was we couldn’t get the turnout we needed. We basically were carrying our positive message, our contrast message and our ground game,” Ryan said.</p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-25" data-gaid="inarticle-25"></div><p class="article__paragraph article__paragraph--left" id="UA4VS5IEMBBHJJMNHQSDXJAIDA"><i>Andrew Tobias covers politics and state government for </i><a href="http://cleveland.com/"><i>Cleveland.com</i></a><i> and The Plain Dealer. Read more of his work </i><a href="https://www.cleveland.com/user/andrewjtobias/posts.html"><i>here</i></a><i>.</i></p><div class="InContent_Center_Background"><div class="InContent_Center_Padding"><div class="ad-observer"></div></div></div><div id="inarticle-26" data-gaid="inarticle-26"></div></div><div class="content-blocker-piano " id="content-blocker-piano"></div><div style="display:none" id="f0frX8yD5iL3b3F" data-fusion-collection="features" data-fusion-type="global/headliner-podcast-widget" data-fusion-name="global headliner podcast widget" data-fusion-message="Could not render component [features:global/headliner-podcast-widget]"></div><div class="author-bio-e__container"><div class="author-bio-e__image-name-container"><a class="author-bio-e__image-link" aria-label="Link to Author Page" rel="nofollow" href="https://www.cleveland.com/staff/andrewjtobias/"><img class="author-bio-e__image" src="https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/https%3A%2F%2Fauthor-service-images-prod-us-east-1.publishing.aws.arc.pub%2Fadvancelocal%2F42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png?auth=ef2dfd67a713e185ecabfedbc7d4ee2ed14a2b58821f8895c97ba551a139f77e&width=180&smart=true&quality=90" alt="Andrew Tobias headshot" loading="lazy" width="100" height="100"/></a><a class="author-bio-e__image-link" aria-label="Link to Author Page" rel="nofollow" href="https://www.cleveland.com/staff/andrewjtobias/"><div class="author-bio-e__name">Andrew Tobias</div></a></div><div class="author-bio-e__bio"><p>Andrew Tobias has worked in journalism since 2008, and has covered government and politics during that time at the local, state and federal levels. Some of his major assignments include the 2016 Republican...<button class="author-bio-e__bio-button"> more</button></p></div><div class="author-bio-e__social"><div class="author-bio-e__social-link"><a href="mailto:atobias@cleveland.com" aria-label="Link to author's email" class="author-bio-e__link"><span class="author-bio-e__email-link"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xml:space="preserve" style="enable-background:new 0 0 64 64" viewBox="0 0 64 64" width="16" height="16" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path d="M53,12H11c-2.761,0-5,2.239-5,5v30c0,2.761,2.239,5,5,5h42c2.761,0,5-2.239,5-5V17C58,14.239,55.761,12,53,12z" fill="none" stroke="#2A2A2A" stroke-width="4" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round"></path><path d="M14,20l18,14l18-14" fill="none" stroke="#2A2A2A" stroke-width="4" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round"></path></svg> atobias@cleveland.com</span></a></div><div class="author-bio-e__social-link"><a href="https://x.com/andrewjtobias" aria-label="Link to author's twitter" class="author-bio-e__link"><span class=""><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xml:space="preserve" style="enable-background:new 0 0 64 64" viewBox="0 0 64 64" width="16" height="16" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path d="M48.1033 6.69061H56.6903L37.9302 28.1322L60 57.3094H42.7195L29.1848 39.6136L13.698 57.3094H5.10583L25.1716 34.3752L4 6.69061H21.7192L33.9534 22.8653L48.1033 6.69061ZM45.0895 52.1697H49.8477L19.1337 11.5604H14.0277L45.0895 52.1697Z" fill="#2A2A2A"></path></svg></span></a></div><div class="author-bio-e__social-link"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/andrewjtobias" aria-label="Link to author's facebook" class="author-bio-e__link"><span class=""><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xml:space="preserve" style="enable-background:new 0 0 64 64" viewBox="0 0 64 64" width="16" height="16" aria-hidden="true" role="presentation"><path d="M60 32.169c0-15.462-12.537-28-28-28s-28 12.538-28 28C4 46.144 14.238 57.728 27.625 59.83V40.265h-7.111v-8.096h7.111V26c0-7.016 4.181-10.895 10.576-10.895 3.064 0 6.269.547 6.269.547v6.891h-3.532c-3.476 0-4.564 2.157-4.564 4.375v5.25h7.765l-1.24 8.096h-6.524v19.568C49.763 57.731 60 46.147 60 32.169z" fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" fill="#2A2A2A"></path></svg></span></a></div></div></div></article></div><div id="sidebar" class="sidebar"></div></main><footer id="footer" class="footer"><nav class="footer__nav" aria-label="footer"><h2 class="footer__nav-title footer__nav-title--hidden">Footer Navigation</h2><div class="footer__nav-wrapper"><div class="footer__nav-header"><img class="footer__nav-header-logo" src="/pf/resources/images/cleveland/logos/logo_footer.png?d=1703" alt="Visit the cleveland.com an Advance Ohio platform in partnership with the Plain Dealer home page" height="49" width="91" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></div><div class="footer__nav-topics"><div><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">About Us</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.advance-ohio.com/contact?utm_source=cleveland.com&utm_medium=footer&utm_campaign=advertise">Advertise with us</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/about-us/">About Cleveland.com</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.advance-ohio.com/about/">About Advance Ohio</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/interact/2018/10/contact_us.html">Contact Us</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.advance-ohio.com/careers/">Career Opportunities</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.plaindealer.com/circulation/independent-contractors/">Delivery Opportunities</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/digitalsubscription/faq/">Audience FAQ</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/accessibility/">Accessibility Statement</a></li></ul></details><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">Subscriptions</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/subscribe/">cleveland.com</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://subscribe.plaindealer.com/">The Plain Dealer</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://link.cleveland.com/join/6fe/signup">Newsletters</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/interact/2018/10/contact_us.html">Sun News</a></li></ul></details><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">Already a Subscriber</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://myaccount.cleveland.com/SecurePage/Payment.aspx">Make a Payment</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://myaccount.cleveland.com/Securepage/dashboard.aspx">Manage your Subscription</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://myaccount.cleveland.com/securepage/VacationStop.aspx">Place a Vacation Hold</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://myaccount.cleveland.com/securepage/MissedPaper.aspx">Delivery Feedback</a></li></ul></details></div><div><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">Cleveland.com Sections</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/news/">News</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/sports/">Sports</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/entertainment/">Entertainment</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/open/">Politics</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/">Opinion</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link"></a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/living/">Living</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/betting/">Betting</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/rentals">Rentals</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://obits.cleveland.com/us/obituaries/cleveland/browse">Obituaries</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/jobs/">Jobs</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://link.cleveland.com/join/6fe/signup">Deals in Your Area</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland">Classifieds</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://autos.cleveland.com/">Autos</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/real-estate">Real Estate</a></li></ul></details><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">Mobile</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/mobile-device/">Mobile Apps</a></li></ul></details><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">Your Regional News Pages</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/topic/lakewood/">Lakewood</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/topic/beachwood/">Beachwood</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/topic/brunswick/">Brunswick</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/topic/strongsville/">Strongsville</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/topic/parma/">Parma & Parma Heights</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/community/">More Communities</a></li></ul></details></div><div><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">More on Cleveland.com</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/sponsor-content-index/?prx_adpz=1109">Sponsor Content</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/placead/">Sell your car</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://hiring.cleveland.com/purchase/post-now/">Post a job</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/search/">Sitemap & search</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/placead/">Post a classified ad</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/placead/">Sell/rent your home</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJkc1COQO0WiZ2CI7dRdwAQ">Videos</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://archives.cleveland.com/?utm_campaign=footer&utm_source=web">Newspapers.com Archive</a></li></ul></details><details class="footer__nav-topicgroup" open=""><summary class="footer__nav-topic">Follow Us</summary><ul class="footer__topic-list"><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://twitter.com/clevelanddotcom">Twitter</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.pinterest.com/clevelanddotcom/">Pinterest</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.facebook.com/pages/clevelandcom/48573742500">Facebook</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://instagram.com/clevelanddotcom">Instagram</a></li><li class="footer__topic-item"><a class="footer__topic-link" href="https://www.cleveland.com/arc/outboundfeeds/rss/?outputType=xml">RSS</a></li></ul></details></div></div><div class="footer__nav-mobile"></div></div></nav><div class="footer_cookies_ad_settings"><ul class="footer_cookies_ad_settings_list"><li><button class="fides-modal-footer-link" id="privacy-choices-button">Your Privacy Choices<img src="/pf/resources/images/common/icons/privacyoptions.svg?d=1703" alt="California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) Opt-Out Icon" height="14px" width="29px" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></button></li><li><a href="https://www.cleveland.com/privacy-policy/">Privacy Policy</a></li><li><span class="list-bar">|</span><a href="https://www.cleveland.com/user-agreement/">User Agreement</a></li><li><span class="list-bar">|</span><a href="https://www.cleveland.com/privacy-policy/#oba_top"><img src="/pf/resources/images/common/logos/ad-choices-arrow.svg?d=1703" alt="Ad Choices icon" width="10" height="10" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/>Ad Choices</a></li></ul></div><div class="footer__divider"></div><div class="footer__disclaimer" aria-label="contentinfo"><h2 class="footer__disclaimer-title footer__disclaimer-title--hidden">Disclaimer</h2><div class="footer__disclaimer-wrapper"><div class="footer__disclaimer-column footer__disclaimer-column--1"><a class="footer__disclaimer-logo-link" href="https://www.advancelocal.com/" id="AdvanceDigitalLogo"><img class="footer__disclaimer-logo-image" src="/pf/resources/images/common/logos/AdvanceLocal_horizontal.svg?d=1703" alt="Advance Local logo" role="img" width="335" height="30" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/></a></div><div class="footer__disclaimer-column footer__disclaimer-column--2"><p class="footer__disclaimer-text">Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our<!-- --> <a href="https://www.cleveland.com/user-agreement/">User Agreement</a>, (updated 8/1/2024) and acknowledgement of our <a href="https://www.cleveland.com/privacy-policy/">Privacy Policy</a>,<!-- --> <!-- --> and <a href="https://www.cleveland.com/privacy-policy/#rights_top">Your Privacy Choices and Rights</a> <!-- --> (updated 10/1/2025).</p><p class="footer__disclaimer-text">© <!-- -->2025<!-- --> Advance Local Media LLC. All rights reserved (<a href="https://www.cleveland.com/aboutus/">About Us</a>).<br/> The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local.</p><p class="footer__disclaimer-text"><a href="https://www.cleveland.com/communityrules/">Community Rules</a> <!-- -->apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site.</p><p class="footer__disclaimer-text"><strong>YouTube's privacy policy</strong> is available <a href="https://policies.google.com/privacy" rel="nofollow" title="YouTube Privacy Policy" lang="en">here</a> and <strong>YouTube's terms of service</strong> is available <a href="https://www.youtube.com/t/terms" rel="nofollow" title="YouTube Terms of Service" lang="en">here</a>.</p><p class="footer__disclaimer-text"><a href="https://www.cleveland.com/privacy-policy/#oba_top"><img src="/pf/resources/images/common/logos/ad-choices-arrow.svg?d=1703" alt="Ad Choices icon" width="10" height="10" loading="lazy" decoding="async"/>Ad Choices</a></p></div></div></div></footer><div class="anchor-modal anchor-modal--hidden" id="anchor-modal"></div><div class="bottom-fixed-modal bottom-fixed-modal--hidden" id="bottom-fixed-modal" data-gaid="bottom-fixed-modal"></div></div><script id="fusion-metadata" type="application/javascript">window.Fusion=window.Fusion||{};Fusion.arcSite="cleveland";Fusion.contextPath="/pf";Fusion.mxId="00000000";Fusion.deployment="1703";Fusion.globalContent={"_id":"TGEUPTW2X5GK3EGJZHV43ABBNY","type":"story","version":"0.10.10","content_elements":[{"_id":"GGDKIHGEONBOPDV3B4JOQL7HP4","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246209},"content":"COLUMBUS, Ohio – Candidates, their affiliates and outside political groups spent almost as much on the 2022 U.S. Senate race in Ohio than in the previous three elections combined, according to campaign finance data."},{"_id":"U2OSTR7CE5EA3JIAFULKJMQLQE","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246210},"content":"The massive spending on last year’s race was fueled by r<a href=\"https://www.cleveland.com/news/2022/10/tim-ryan-outraises-jd-vance-blowing-out-state-record-in-final-pre-election-fundraising-period-for-ohios-us-senate-race.html\" target=\"_blank\">ecord-busting personal fundraising by the Democratic nominee</a>, a big tech <a href=\"https://www.cleveland.com/news/2022/07/super-pac-discloses-raising-spending-millions-helping-jd-vance-win-ohios-us-senate-republican-primary.html\" target=\"_blank\">cash infusion in the GOP primary</a> for the eventual Republican candidate and millions of dollars spent by outside groups. About $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race last year, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups, according to a cleveland.com/Plain Dealer review of federal campaign finance data."},{"_id":"AINOMKQUXRBBRJMQ6H7GBQWLY4","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672344873410},"content":"That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three races combined, according to data compiled by the nonpartisan <a href=\"http://opensecrets.org/\" target=\"_blank\">OpenSecrets.org</a> – $37.7 million for the 2018 race, in which Sen. Sherrod Brown won reelection over Republican Jim Renacci; $91 million on the 2016 Senate race, in which Republican Sen. Rob Portman defeated Democratic former governor Ted Strickland; and $82.3 million in 2012, when Brown defeated Republican Josh Mandel."},{"_id":"F3L45TWF35COFF4OBTRRWWI5Q4","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246211},"content":"Last year’s race pitted Tim Ryan, a Democratic congressman from the Youngstown area, against J.D. Vance, a Republican investor/author from Cincinnati, to replace retiring GOP Sen. Rob Portman. Vance won the November election by 6 percentage points, a comfortable win but relatively competitive compared to the rest of Ohio’s statewide elections, which Republican candidates otherwise won by double digits."},{"_id":"P7L2UEB525HMDIL6KRNXEBAD3M","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246212},"content":"In addition to the general election, which drew heavy spending, the Republican primary election also was hotly competitive, since it presented a rare opportunity to run for an open seat in a Republican-leaning state. Vance ultimately won, defeating four well-funded opponents. The Democratic primary, in which Ryan easily defeated two opponents, was much less competitive and saw much less spending."},{"_id":"MU5A65NLPFDBJBVFGZK4SGOFQM","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246213},"content":"The ballooning cash spent on the 2022 Senate race could be a harbinger of things to come. Control of the U.S. Senate, in which Democrats hold a slim majority, will be up or grabs again in 2024. The Senate map that year is expected to favor Republicans, with three incumbent Democrats – Ohio’s Brown, plus Sen. John Tester of Montana and Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia – running for reelection in states that ex-President Donald Trump won in 2020."},{"_id":"EG3DEVHIUFDHNIEW2OMUDE3HWY","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246214},"content":"Trump won Ohio by 8 percentage points in 2020, compared to his 17-point win in Montana and his 39-point victory in West Virginia, which means Ohio’s U.S. Senate race likely will be a top priority for both national Democrats and Republicans."},{"_id":"6FI35O22PVB4BPENTMBPVB6FEQ","type":"header","level":1,"additional_properties":{"_id":1672343681782},"content":"<b>Breaking down spending in this year’s race</b>"},{"_id":"C3QU5YYVQBFGRN6X5OBMHFKGX4","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246216},"content":"A majority of the spending from official candidate committees in last year’s Senate race was due to Ryan’s prolific fundraising."},{"_id":"2WY2HOOMBNASDIRRLZKYDK5UBM","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246217},"content":"Ryan and an affiliated committee spent $60.7 million, nearly two-thirds of the $93.9 million raised by all campaigns and their affiliates, and compared to the nearly $18.5 million spent by Vance and an affiliate."},{"_id":"5P4PGJ25LZAB3KWAJAKZTF76KM","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246218},"content":"The $53.4 million raised directly by Ryan’s campaign was a record, almost double the previous record of $28.7 million set by Brown in 2018."},{"_id":"J6CMDARPSFFKNC3XVLMSA47WI4","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246221},"content":"As we’ve previously reported, a unique dynamic of the race was the large amounts of personal money Republican candidates’ spent on their campaigns. In all, Republicans candidates loaned themselves $30.5 million. Most of that, $18.1 million, is the money Mike Gibbons, a Cleveland businessman, lost while unsuccessfully running in the Republican primary election. Vance loaned his campaign $1.4 million, while Ryan did not loan his campaign any money."},{"_id":"YNXRKEG6GREYLAFLOTVXEKJKFA","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672343681787},"content":"Here’s a table breaking down the candidate-by-candidate campaign-finance data. Note, the topline spending exceeds fundraising because it doesn’t include personal candidate loans and affiliated committee transfers, among other quirks in how federal campaign finance data is recorded."},{"_id":"N6UBWTCJMRBPDGZYUF7DQ2LQ64","type":"raw_html","additional_properties":{"_id":"2GEZZX3ZY5DG3BXZBNLFETFIXA"},"content":"<style type=\"text/css\">\r\n\ttable.tableizer-table {\r\n\t\tfont-size: 12px;\r\n\t\tborder: 1px solid #CCC; \r\n\t\tfont-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;\r\n\t} \r\n\t.tableizer-table td {\r\n\t\tpadding: 4px;\r\n\t\tmargin: 3px;\r\n\t\tborder: 1px solid #CCC;\r\n\t}\r\n\t.tableizer-table th {\r\n\t\tbackground-color: #104E8B; \r\n\t\tcolor: #FFF;\r\n\t\tfont-weight: bold;\r\n\t}\r\n</style>\r\n<table class=\"tableizer-table\">\r\n<thead><tr class=\"tableizer-firstrow\"><th>Committee</th><th>Amount raised</th><th>Amount Spent</th><th>Candidate loans</th><th>Party</th></tr></thead><tbody>\r\n <tr><td>Tim Ryan for Ohio</td><td>$53,399,343</td><td>$55,293,286</td><td>$0</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>J.D. Vance for Senate</td><td>$11,048,086</td><td>$13,980,514</td><td>$1,400,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Gibbons for Ohio</td><td>$19,308,077</td><td>$19,281,487</td><td>$18,170,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Dolan for Ohio</td><td>$11,294,797</td><td>$11,200,399</td><td>$2,607,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Timken for Ohio</td><td>$8,706,571</td><td>$8,698,358</td><td>$4,060,000</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Bernie Moreno for Ohio</td><td>$6,860,887</td><td>$6,860,522</td><td>$3,806,142</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Citizens for Josh Mandel</td><td>$3,266,385</td><td>$7,627,693</td><td>$0</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Morgan Harper for Ohio</td><td>$1,318,601</td><td>$1,306,245</td><td>$0</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Mark Pukita for US Senate</td><td>$504,103</td><td>$898,426</td><td>$461,143</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>TOTALS</td><td>$83,755,505</td><td>$125,146,930</td><td>$30,504,285</td><td></td></tr>\r\n</tbody></table>"},{"_id":"IL55XKHGCZG2HIH5WYVLUO3CL4","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672343681789},"content":"But Republican groups made up the lion’s share of the $103.7 million that outside groups spent in Ohio. The largest outside spender was the Senate Leadership Fund, which is closely aligned with Republican U.S. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell. Along with a nonprofit affiliate, the McConnell-backed groups spent $36.2 million helping Vance win the race. Another pro-Vance group, the Protect Ohio Values Super PAC, spent $19.5 million helping Vance. A single donor, California billionaire Peter Thiel, who is Vance’s former boss, was the group’s largest funder, giving it $15 million."},{"_id":"KOUB6OSLSRBUPC6TIRVUHJ3POY","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672342246220},"content":"In comparison, outside Democratic groups spent around $14.1 million on the race. The two largest ones were the Save America Fund, a semi-official pro-Ryan PAC that spent $8 million helping Ryan and attacking Vance, and $2.8 million spent by the Future Forward PAC, a national progressive PAC that spent $2.8 million on anti-Vance attack ads."},{"_id":"ECY7LIMIRNGPZGBUEOJNWUGXTY","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672343681791},"content":"Here’s a table breaking down spending by outside groups. The data’s source is OpenSecrets.org."},{"_id":"KMECZKYUQVC27OYYQCFPXUGJIQ","type":"raw_html","additional_properties":{"_id":"IYZPMUVYSBFGZJE3RSYXVV3QFI"},"content":"<style type=\"text/css\">\r\n\ttable.tableizer-table {\r\n\t\tfont-size: 12px;\r\n\t\tborder: 1px solid #CCC; \r\n\t\tfont-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;\r\n\t} \r\n\t.tableizer-table td {\r\n\t\tpadding: 4px;\r\n\t\tmargin: 3px;\r\n\t\tborder: 1px solid #CCC;\r\n\t}\r\n\t.tableizer-table th {\r\n\t\tbackground-color: #104E8B; \r\n\t\tcolor: #FFF;\r\n\t\tfont-weight: bold;\r\n\t}\r\n</style>\r\n<table class=\"tableizer-table\">\r\n<thead><tr class=\"tableizer-firstrow\"><th>Outside groups</th><th>Amount spent</th><th>Affiliation</th><th>Party</th></tr></thead><tbody>\r\n <tr><td>Senate Leadershp Fund</td><td>$32,465,089.00</td><td>pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Protect Ohio Values</td><td>$19,478,331.58</td><td>pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Club for Growth Action</td><td>$8,178,324.00</td><td>pro-Josh Mandel</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Save America Fund</td><td>$8,001,724.84</td><td>Pro-Tim Ryan</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>USA Freedom Fund</td><td>$5,469,032.00</td><td>pro-Josh Mandel</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>One Nation</td><td>$3,800,000.00</td><td>Pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Ohio Leads PAC</td><td>$3,394,454.00</td><td>pro-Jane Timken</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Buckeye Leadership Fund</td><td>$2,933,163.00</td><td>pro-Matt Dolan</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Future Forward PAC</td><td>$2,868,040.95</td><td>Pro-Tim Ryan</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Make America Great Again</td><td>$2,398,187.00</td><td>Pro-J.D. Vance</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>Republican Accountability Project</td><td>$2,270,384.00</td><td>pro-Tim Ryan</td><td>Democratic</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>WFW Action Fund</td><td>$2,018,636.00</td><td>pro-Jane Timken</td><td>Republican</td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>All remaining groups</td><td>$10,385,129.00</td><td> </td><td> </td></tr>\r\n <tr><td>OUTSIDE GROUP TOTAL</td><td>$103,660,495.37</td><td> </td><td></td></tr>\r\n</tbody></table>"},{"_id":"3R4DOWOHXBFQDOV33GN5V3RVYM","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672343681793},"content":"Campaign spending was a hot topic for both candidates last year. Vance frequently complained about Ryan’s large national donor base, which he said was evidence of his popularity with elite coastal Democrats. Republicans, meanwhile, privately groused about Vance’s poor fundraising."},{"_id":"RYAIGIQN6RAI3ANC34COHU26LU","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580194},"content":"Vance also said, as a first-time candidate, he was surprised how much political advertising matters, since it’s often the primary source of information voters get about candidates."},{"_id":"IVN63NEJVZC3DDHW5RSV4RK5EM","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580195},"content":"“I’ve run into a political opponent who’s very hot in the Acela Corridor,” Vance said, referring to the rail line that runs from Washington, D.C., to Boston, during an October speech at a conservative policy conference in Steubenville. “And $30 million has poured into the race. I’m not kidding.”"},{"_id":"JL7DP7I26NE3LGD4KJP7SKT55I","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580196},"content":"Ryan, meanwhile, frequently said Vance had “two donors”: McConnell and Thiel. As the November election neared, and as national Democrats passed on a major investment in the race, prioritizing races they deemed to be more winnable, Ryan also cast his campaign as lacking in resources, despite his huge individual fundraising advantage."},{"_id":"SWZIPALYYVAPHLPZTMJYF74E3U","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580197},"content":"<a href=\"https://youtu.be/HEedrQ7j6qc\" target=\"_blank\">During a post-election appearance at a conference for centrist Democrats in Washington, D.C.</a>, Ryan complained that national Democrats left him on the field. Another $10 million, he said, would have helped fund a better ground game that could have countered the <a href=\"https://www.cleveland.com/news/2022/10/early-voting-data-in-ohio-showing-signs-of-lagging-turnout-in-urban-areas.html\" target=\"_blank\">lower turnout in urban areas</a> that hurt Ryan and other Ohio Democrats."},{"_id":"4UJYFUPHR5C5PHERTVOWRBBOCM","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580198},"content":"That left his campaign to cover costs, like negative advertising, that typically would be picked up by outside groups."},{"_id":"6Z7YVTFQLZH77PN7IU562QT6TI","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580199},"content":"“Our problem was we couldn’t get the turnout we needed. We basically were carrying our positive message, our contrast message and our ground game,” Ryan said."},{"_id":"UA4VS5IEMBBHJJMNHQSDXJAIDA","type":"text","additional_properties":{"_id":1672346580200},"content":"<i>Andrew Tobias covers politics and state government for </i><a href=\"http://cleveland.com/\"><i>Cleveland.com</i></a><i> and The Plain Dealer. Read more of his work </i><a href=\"https://www.cleveland.com/user/andrewjtobias/posts.html\"><i>here</i></a><i>.</i>"}],"created_date":"2022-12-29T19:30:44.801Z","revision":{"revision_id":"OTZHVMDUANB4VE7NHMGMZGJ64U","parent_id":"42TECCGXSJCHVF4D273Z5K47AY","editions":["default"],"branch":"default","published":true},"last_updated_date":"2024-09-19T01:58:16.476Z","canonical_website":"cleveland","headlines":{"basic":"Ohio’s 2022 U.S. Senate race shatters spending records","meta_title":"","mobile":"","native":"","print":"","tablet":"","web":""},"owner":{"sponsored":false,"id":"advancelocal"},"address":{},"workflow":{"status_code":1},"subheadlines":{"basic":""},"description":{"basic":"This year, $197.6 million was spent on the U.S. Senate race, including almost $103.7 million from outside groups. That compares to $211 million spent on the previous three Senate races combined."},"language":"","label":{},"source":{"name":"advancelocal","source_type":"staff","system":"composer"},"taxonomy":{"categories":[{"_id":"387","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Politics>Elections","score":1},{"_id":"386","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Politics","score":1},{"_id":"52","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Business and Finance","score":0.7776},{"_id":"483","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Sports","score":0.7483},{"_id":"484","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Sports>American Football","score":0.6237},{"_id":"53","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Business and Finance>Business","score":0.6221},{"_id":"8YPBBL","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Politics>Civic affairs","score":0.5055},{"_id":"388","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Politics>Political Issues & policy","score":0.4915},{"_id":"8VZQHL","classifier":"iab_content_taxonomy","name":"Events","score":0.3451}],"content_topics":[{"_id":"Q29468","label":"Republican Party (United States)","score":1},{"_id":"Q2101438","label":"Political action committee","score":1},{"_id":"Q29552","label":"Democratic Party (United States)","score":1},{"_id":"Q976676","label":"Jim Renacci","score":1},{"_id":"Q513960","label":"Tim Ryan (Ohio politician)","score":1},{"_id":"Q926069","label":"Rob Portman","score":1},{"_id":"Q54070","label":"Government","score":1},{"_id":"Q7029555","label":"American politicians","score":1},{"_id":"Q4103183","label":"Politics","score":1},{"_id":"Q4273219","label":"Elections","score":1},{"_id":"Q6734171","label":"Politics of the United States","score":1},{"_id":"Q6289137","label":"Josh Mandel","score":0.9782},{"_id":"Q5027774","label":"Campaign finance in the United States","score":0.964},{"_id":"Q66096","label":"United States Senate","score":0.9614},{"_id":"Q1410960","label":"United States","score":0.9461},{"_id":"Q1161355","label":"Fundraising","score":0.9227},{"_id":"Q1397","label":"Ohio","score":0.8744},{"_id":"Q7993145","label":"United States presidential elections","score":0.85},{"_id":"Q28935729","label":"J. D. Vance","score":0.8378},{"_id":"Q381880","label":"Sherrod Brown","score":0.8078},{"_id":"Q538868","label":"Joe Manchin","score":0.7939},{"_id":"Q7707636","label":"American political people","score":0.7637},{"_id":"Q465295","label":"Ted Strickland","score":0.7464},{"_id":"Q8445480","label":"Federal elections of the United States","score":0.7452},{"_id":"Q5850917","label":"Federal government of the United States","score":0.7423},{"_id":"Q5626636","label":"Legislative branch of the United States government","score":0.741},{"_id":"Q113184095","label":"Save America","score":0.7322},{"_id":"Q355522","label":"Mitch McConnell","score":0.7102},{"_id":"Q7458833","label":"Candidates for President of the United States","score":0.6831},{"_id":"Q22686","label":"Donald Trump","score":0.6707},{"_id":"Q4817933","label":"Attack ad","score":0.667},{"_id":"Q1815888","label":"Campaign advertising","score":0.6641},{"_id":"Q705525","label":"Peter Thiel","score":0.6441},{"_id":"Q286036","label":"The Plain Dealer","score":0.6405},{"_id":"Q5753390","label":"Politicians","score":0.6271},{"_id":"Q1352232","label":"Campaign finance","score":0.6091},{"_id":"Q7235741","label":"Democracy","score":0.5806},{"_id":"Q6809866","label":"Political events","score":0.5771},{"_id":"Q7146497","label":"Political science","score":0.5675},{"_id":"Q1212","label":"Montana","score":0.5622},{"_id":"Q257437","label":"Negative campaigning","score":0.5613},{"_id":"Q9091378","label":"Presidency of the United States","score":0.5557},{"_id":"Q2944364","label":"OpenSecrets","score":0.5556},{"_id":"Q1371","label":"West Virginia","score":0.5428},{"_id":"Q8247581","label":"American political philosophy","score":0.5117},{"_id":"Q8689660","label":"November events","score":0.5093},{"_id":"Q6992294","label":"Accountability","score":0.4908},{"_id":"Q6613461","label":"Political activism","score":0.4844},{"_id":"Q40231","label":"Election","score":0.4711},{"_id":"Q9205879","label":"Public sphere","score":0.4566},{"_id":"Q1339847","label":"Voter turnout","score":0.4563},{"_id":"Q669262","label":"Primary election","score":0.4385},{"_id":"Q7650916","label":"National upper houses","score":0.4373},{"_id":"Q49812401","label":"Political campaigning","score":0.4314},{"_id":"Q99","label":"California","score":0.4157},{"_id":"Q11701","label":"United States House of Representatives","score":0.4084},{"_id":"Q216820","label":"Youngstown, Ohio","score":0.3887},{"_id":"Q100","label":"Boston","score":0.3856},{"_id":"Q61","label":"Washington, D.C.","score":0.3805},{"_id":"Q7801818","label":"Members of the United States Congress","score":0.3783},{"_id":"Q13299854","label":"United States presidential campaigns","score":0.365},{"_id":"Q55975323","label":"Campaigning","score":0.3634},{"_id":"Q6418705","label":"United States Senate elections","score":0.3586},{"_id":"Q7130129","label":"Presidents of the United States","score":0.3555},{"_id":"Q6441213","label":"United States Congresses","score":0.3499},{"_id":"Q8495123","label":"Governance","score":0.3496},{"_id":"Q1156854","label":"Policy","score":0.3481},{"_id":"Q6453105","label":"Executive branch of the government of the United States","score":0.3412},{"_id":"Q163740","label":"Nonprofit organization","score":0.3328},{"_id":"Q11708087","label":"Presidencies","score":0.3312},{"_id":"Q7146194","label":"State governments of the United States","score":0.3296},{"_id":"Q63686823","label":"People associated with United States presidential elections","score":0.3273},{"_id":"Q43196","label":"Cincinnati","score":0.3212},{"_id":"Q8654554","label":"Republican Party presidents of the United States","score":0.3172},{"_id":"Q6132159","label":"Political corruption","score":0.3128},{"_id":"Q7141244","label":"Society of the United States","score":0.3122},{"_id":"Q6267239","label":"Social liberalism","score":0.311},{"_id":"Q7014667","label":"Activism","score":0.3097},{"_id":"Q8247562","label":"American political candidates","score":0.3076},{"_id":"Q14841283","label":"Presidencies of the United States","score":0.3053}],"entities":[{"_id":"Q976676","label":"Jim Renacci","score":0.865,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician,Congressman"},{"_id":"Q513960","label":"Tim Ryan (Ohio politician)","score":0.768,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician"},{"_id":"Q6289137","label":"Josh Mandel","score":0.7393,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician,OfficeHolder"},{"_id":"Q28935729","label":"J. D. Vance","score":0.6331,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician"},{"_id":"Q381880","label":"Sherrod Brown","score":0.6105,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician"},{"_id":"Q538868","label":"Joe Manchin","score":0.6,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician,OfficeHolder"},{"_id":"Q926069","label":"Rob Portman","score":0.5773,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician,President"},{"_id":"Q465295","label":"Ted Strickland","score":0.564,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician,OfficeHolder"},{"_id":"Q113184095","label":"Save America","score":0.5533,"type":"Agent,Organisation"},{"_id":"Q286036","label":"The Plain Dealer","score":0.5504,"type":"Work,WrittenWork,PeriodicalLiterature,Newspaper"},{"_id":"Q355522","label":"Mitch McConnell","score":0.5367,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician"},{"_id":"Q705525","label":"Peter Thiel","score":0.4868,"type":"Agent,Person"},{"_id":"Q29468","label":"Republican Party (United States)","score":0.4454,"type":"Agent,Organisation,PoliticalParty"},{"_id":"Q1397","label":"Ohio","score":0.4379,"type":"Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion"},{"_id":"Q66096","label":"United States Senate","score":0.393,"type":"Agent,Organisation,Legislature"},{"_id":"Q2944364","label":"OpenSecrets","score":0.3778,"type":"Agent,Organisation"},{"_id":"Q22686","label":"Donald Trump","score":0.3757,"type":"Agent,Person,Politician"},{"_id":"Q29552","label":"Democratic Party (United States)","score":0.3708,"type":"Agent,Organisation,PoliticalParty"},{"_id":"Q1212","label":"Montana","score":0.3226,"type":"Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion"},{"_id":"Q99","label":"California","score":0.3141,"type":"Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion"},{"_id":"Q1371","label":"West Virginia","score":0.3115,"type":"Place,PopulatedPlace,Region,AdministrativeRegion"},{"_id":"Q11701","label":"United States House of Representatives","score":0.3086,"type":"Agent,Organisation,Legislature"},{"custom_id":"PER3dcb75dfc","label":"Mike Gibbons","type":"Person"},{"custom_id":"PER9592955c5","label":"McConnell","type":"Person"},{"custom_id":"PERec2ef0c9f","label":"Thiel","type":"Person"},{"custom_id":"PER2d1e83062","label":"Ryan","type":"Person"},{"custom_id":"PERb9317e004","label":"John Tester","type":"Person"},{"custom_id":"PER18f285592","label":"Brown","type":"Person"},{"custom_id":"ent0007","label":"Tim Ryan","type":"Agent,Person,Politician"}],"primary_section":{"_id":"/news","_website":"cleveland","type":"section","version":"0.6.0","name":"News","description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","path":"/news","parent_id":"/","parent":{"default":"/"},"additional_properties":{"original":{"_id":"/news","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio news, Cleveland Ohio news Ohio local news, Ohio breaking news, latest news, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Cleveland & Ohio Local News","headline":"Ohio Real-Time News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/news"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/news/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"News","order":{"toprail":1001,"ellipsis":1014,"native-app-news":1001,"native-app-test":1001,"photocenter":1001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","native-app-test":"/","photocenter":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-app-test":["/"],"photocenter":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section"}}},"sections":[{"_id":"/news","_website":"cleveland","type":"section","version":"0.6.0","name":"News","description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","path":"/news","parent_id":"/","parent":{"default":"/"},"additional_properties":{"original":{"_id":"/news","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio news, Cleveland Ohio news Ohio local news, Ohio breaking news, latest news, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Cleveland & Ohio Local News","headline":"Ohio Real-Time News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/news"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/news/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"News","order":{"toprail":1001,"ellipsis":1014,"native-app-news":1001,"native-app-test":1001,"photocenter":1001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","native-app-test":"/","photocenter":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-app-test":["/"],"photocenter":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section"}},"_website_section_id":"cleveland./news"},{"_id":"/open","_website":"cleveland","type":"section","version":"0.6.0","name":"Ohio Politics","description":"Get Ohio political news, views and blogs from the Plain Dealer. Find Ohio candidates and politicians news, election results and more at cleveland.com.","path":"/open","parent_id":"/","parent":{"default":"/"},"additional_properties":{"original":{"_id":"/open","site":{"site_description":"Get Ohio political news, views and blogs from the Plain Dealer. Find Ohio candidates and politicians news, election results and more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"ohio politics, political news, political views, political blogs","site_title":"Ohio Politics & Election News","headline":"Ohio Politics","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/open"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/open/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"State Politics","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Ohio Politics","order":{"toprail":2001,"ellipsis":2002,"native-app-news":1010},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/politics","ellipsis":"/politics","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-election":null},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/politics"],"ellipsis":["/politics"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-election":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section"}},"_website_section_id":"cleveland./open"},{"_id":"/politics","_website":"cleveland","type":"section","version":"0.6.0","name":"National Politics","description":"Get United States national politics news and election results.","path":"/politics","parent_id":"/","parent":{"default":"/"},"additional_properties":{"original":{"_id":"/politics","site":{"site_description":"Get United States national politics news and election results.","site_keywords":"us politics,presidential race,united states president,election results, ohio election results, united states congress,politics news","site_title":"National Politics: U.S. political news, blogs and election results","headline":"National Politics","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/politics"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/politics/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Politics & Elections","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"National Politics","order":{"toprail":1005,"ellipsis":1020},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":null,"hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":[],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section"}},"_website_section_id":"cleveland./politics"}],"tags":[{"description":"@lll","slug":"lll","text":"@lll"},{"description":"@yyy","slug":"yyy","text":"@yyy"},{"description":"ohio-senate-race-2022","slug":"ohio-senate-race-2022","text":"ohio-senate-race-2022"},{"description":"ohio-senate-race-2024","slug":"ohio-senate-race-2024","text":"ohio-senate-race-2024"}],"keywords":[{"keyword":"vance","score":0.4726328730655617,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":27},{"keyword":"ohio","score":0.35766596825170244,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":17},{"keyword":"race","score":0.3483476655946782,"tag":"noun","frequency":24},{"keyword":"ryan","score":0.33961442797110014,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":25},{"keyword":"group","score":0.3097650997978258,"tag":"noun","frequency":13},{"keyword":"campaign","score":0.22682387518212543,"tag":"noun","frequency":16},{"keyword":"spending","score":0.1906518523363055,"tag":"noun","frequency":13},{"keyword":"election","score":0.15313305931316717,"tag":"noun","frequency":10},{"keyword":"pac","score":0.13495238930864573,"tag":"noun","frequency":6},{"keyword":"money","score":0.13209516602879215,"tag":"noun","frequency":5},{"keyword":"candidate","score":0.12188099365232563,"tag":"noun","frequency":11},{"keyword":"Vance","score":0.11059026604599087,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":13},{"keyword":"senate","score":0.10611544199088589,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":10},{"keyword":"brown","score":0.10203617713690703,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":7},{"keyword":"groups","score":0.10112247858311814,"tag":"noun","frequency":9},{"keyword":"record","score":0.08524541381058055,"tag":"noun","frequency":4},{"keyword":"democrats","score":0.08415395956854879,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":8},{"keyword":"Ryan","score":0.08339001654869513,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":12},{"keyword":"affiliate","score":0.07898613517413931,"tag":"noun","frequency":6},{"keyword":"Ohio","score":0.07781074625785749,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":7},{"keyword":"fundraising","score":0.07653987887747252,"tag":"noun","frequency":7},{"keyword":"sen","score":0.054489255986876775,"tag":"proper_noun","frequency":5},{"keyword":"data","score":0.049565041742136794,"tag":"noun","frequency":6},{"keyword":"reelection","score":0.04843489421055713,"tag":"noun","frequency":4},{"keyword":"candidates","score":0.04715117525638026,"tag":"noun","frequency":6}],"topics":[{"_id":"53457677e4b02fdfdb579d29","name":"Republicans","score":0.8119071477268848,"uid":"if"},{"_id":"53457668e4b02fdfdb579d27","name":"Campaigns and Campaign Finance","score":0.9966549372488918,"uid":"nk"},{"_id":"5345772ce4b02fdfdb579d3c","name":"Lobbying and Advocacy","score":0.6359916313305741,"uid":"qd"},{"_id":"53457670e4b02fdfdb579d28","name":"Democrats","score":0.5487620941429642,"uid":"vt"},{"_id":"53457692e4b02fdfdb579d2d","name":"Congressional Elections","score":0.5235062603361144,"uid":"no"}],"auxiliaries":[{"_id":"5849","name":"Bank of America","uid":"c2e"},{"_id":"7591","name":"Politics/Political","uid":"a2s"},{"_id":"8317","name":"AFAR keyword block list","uid":"thn"},{"_id":"5518","name":"Alabama GOP representatives","uid":"at1"},{"_id":"6051","name":"Race_terminology-Senate Race","uid":"nhd"},{"_id":"5850","name":"Banking","uid":"o1w"},{"_id":"7889","name":"JD Vance","uid":"r26"},{"_id":"6050","name":"Race_terminology-Republican Party","uid":"5tr"},{"_id":"7888","name":"Josh Mandel","uid":"9xq"},{"_id":"8053","name":"Safe from negative Rocket Mortgage topics","uid":"324"},{"_id":"7890","name":"Mike Gibbons","uid":"4wn"},{"_id":"5522","name":"Tim Ryan","uid":"k43"},{"_id":"6931","name":"Safe from Piqray keywords","uid":"8d5"},{"_id":"7327","name":"Goldman Sachs keyword block list","uid":"ytp"},{"_id":"8185","name":"Disney keyword blocklist","uid":"dss"},{"_id":"6046","name":"Race_terminology-Democratic Party","uid":"cgj"},{"_id":"5479","name":"Safe from negative news","uid":"yht"}],"named_entities":[{"_id":"mike-gibbons","name":"Mike Gibbons","type":"person","score":0.3005949035140369},{"_id":"ted-strickland","name":"Ted Strickland","type":"person","score":0.28874089507362644},{"_id":"j-d-vance","name":"J.D. Vance","type":"person","score":0.2769022971613791},{"_id":"josh-mandel","name":"Josh Mandel","type":"person","score":0.2710201620490704},{"_id":"steubenville","name":"Steubenville","type":"location","score":0.2684763337969693},{"_id":"republican-u-s-senate","name":"Republican U.S. Senate","type":"organization","score":0.2507556007724133},{"_id":"jim-renacci","name":"Jim Renacci","type":"person","score":0.2482117725203121},{"_id":"peter-thiel","name":"Peter Thiel","type":"person","score":0.24476936483338693},{"_id":"tim-ryan","name":"Tim Ryan","type":"person","score":0.23636990699342425},{"_id":"youngstown","name":"Youngstown","type":"location","score":0.21999707078985453},{"_id":"rob-portman","name":"Rob Portman","type":"person","score":0.20768353911078813},{"_id":"sherrod-brown","name":"Sherrod Brown","type":"person","score":0.19552735360907722},{"_id":"joe-manchin","name":"Joe Manchin","type":"person","score":0.19302374196050603},{"_id":"u-s-senate","name":"U.S. Senate","type":"organization","score":0.1468148164039802},{"_id":"montana","name":"Montana","type":"location","score":0.14364985863651508},{"_id":"mitch-mcconnell","name":"Mitch McConnell","type":"person","score":0.13019359333182304},{"_id":"cincinnati","name":"Cincinnati","type":"location","score":0.12832907234258203},{"_id":"west-virginia","name":"West Virginia","type":"location","score":0.12706603193227486},{"_id":"cleveland","name":"Cleveland","type":"location","score":0.11341900959404566},{"_id":"ohio","name":"Ohio","type":"location","score":0.10853041778732975},{"_id":"boston","name":"Boston","type":"location","score":0.10384021385404982},{"_id":"d-c-","name":"D.C.","type":"location","score":0.09386615362275536},{"_id":"gop","name":"GOP","type":"organization","score":0.09014127154926106},{"_id":"california","name":"California","type":"location","score":0.08586776690156157},{"_id":"senate","name":"Senate","type":"organization","score":0.07886771558223579},{"_id":"donald-trump","name":"Donald Trump","type":"person","score":0.06930437730391324},{"_id":"future-forward-pac","name":"Future Forward PAC","type":"organization","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"columbus","name":"COLUMBUS","type":"location","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"save-america-fund","name":"Save America Fund","type":"organization","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"andrew-tobias","name":"Andrew Tobias","type":"person","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"protect-ohio-values-super-pac","name":"Protect Ohio Values Super PAC","type":"organization","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"mcconnell-backed","name":"McConnell-backed","type":"location","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"john-tester","name":"John Tester","type":"person","score":0.06731741543549395},{"_id":"washington","name":"Washington","type":"location","score":0.05040264569766054}]},"promo_items":{"basic":{"_id":"J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE","additional_properties":{"countryId":227,"fullSizeResizeUrl":"/resizer/3iGlxowQE-f3Q8xK_UWT7EpeeMw=/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","galleries":[],"ingestionMethod":"manual","iptc_job_identifier":"WX417","iptc_source":"FR66830 AP","iptc_title":"FRE","keywords":[""],"mime_type":"image/jpeg","originalName":"ryan vance.jpg","originalUrl":"https://cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/advancelocal/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","proxyUrl":"/resizer/3iGlxowQE-f3Q8xK_UWT7EpeeMw=/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","published":true,"resizeUrl":"/resizer/3iGlxowQE-f3Q8xK_UWT7EpeeMw=/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","restricted":false,"takenOn":"2022-08-05T17:02:17Z","thumbnailResizeUrl":"/resizer/RY6_yhi6pEvesh3AaH5ptbPEMwk=/300x0/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","usage_instructions":"PHOTO BY PAUL VERNON, LEFT, AND LM OTERO, RIGHT","version":0,"template_id":7},"address":{"country_name":"USA"},"auth":{"1":"e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf"},"caption":"This combination of photos shows Ohio Democratic Senate candidate Rep. Tim Ryan, D-Ohio, on March 28, 2022, in Wilberforce, Ohio, left, and Republican candidate JD Vance on Aug. 5, 2022, in Dallas. (AP Photo)","copyright":"Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved","created_date":"2022-10-28T13:54:54Z","credits":{"affiliation":[{"name":"AP","type":"author"}],"by":[{"byline":"LM Otero","name":"LM Otero","type":"author"}]},"height":715,"image_type":"photograph","last_updated_date":"2022-10-28T13:54:54Z","licensable":false,"owner":{"id":"advancelocal","sponsored":false},"slug":"Election 2022 Senate Ohio","source":{"additional_properties":{"editor":"photo center"},"edit_url":"","system":"photo center"},"subtitle":"Tim Ryan JD Vance","taxonomy":{"associated_tasks":[]},"type":"image","url":"https://cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/advancelocal/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","version":"0.10.9","width":1024,"syndication":{},"creditIPTC":"AP","country_name":"United States","resized_urls":{"large":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90","medium":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=800&smart=true&quality=90","small":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=500&smart=true&quality=90","x_small":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=180&smart=true&quality=90"}}},"related_content":{"basic":[],"redirect":[]},"distributor":{"category":"staff","name":"advancelocal","subcategory":""},"planning":{"scheduling":{"planned_publish_date":"2022-12-29T19:28:00Z"},"story_length":{"character_count_actual":6689,"inch_count_actual":7,"line_count_actual":45,"word_count_actual":1044}},"display_date":"2023-01-05T15:00:00Z","credits":{"by":[{"_id":"andrewjtobias","type":"author","version":"0.5.8","name":"Andrew Tobias","org":"Columbus, Ohio","image":{"url":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/arc-authors/advancelocal/42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png","version":"0.5.8"},"description":"","social_links":[{"site":"email","url":"atobias@cleveland.com"},{"site":"facebook","url":"https://www.facebook.com/andrewjtobias"},{"site":"twitter","url":"andrewjtobias"}],"socialLinks":[{"site":"email","url":"atobias@cleveland.com","deprecated":true,"deprecation_msg":"Please use social_links."},{"site":"facebook","url":"https://www.facebook.com/andrewjtobias","deprecated":true,"deprecation_msg":"Please use social_links."},{"site":"twitter","url":"andrewjtobias","deprecated":true,"deprecation_msg":"Please use social_links."}],"additional_properties":{"original":{"_id":"andrewjtobias","status":true,"bio":"","byline":"Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com","firstName":"Andrew ","lastName":"Tobias","twitter":"andrewjtobias","education":[],"mt_author_id":"11064223","podcasts":[],"last_updated_date":"2024-01-31T13:11:04.216Z","books":[],"facebook":"https://www.facebook.com/andrewjtobias","awards":[],"email":"atobias@cleveland.com","image":"https://s3.amazonaws.com/arc-authors/advancelocal/42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png","middleName":"J.","location":"Columbus, Ohio","role":"Chief politics reporter","longBio":"Andrew Tobias has worked in journalism since 2008, and has covered government and politics during that time at the local, state and federal levels. Some of his major assignments include the 2016 Republican National Convention in Cleveland and U.S. Senate campaigns in 2018 and 2022. He has received numerous awards from the Associated Press of Ohio for investigative reporting and news reporting, and regularly appears on radio and television to discuss Ohio politics. He previously worked for newspapers in Dayton and Delaware (Ohio.) He is a 2008 graduate of Otterbein University and a lifelong Ohio resident."}}}]},"subtype":"article","first_publish_date":"2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z","websites":{"cleveland":{"website_section":{"_id":"/news","_website":"cleveland","type":"section","version":"0.6.0","name":"News","description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","path":"/news","parent_id":"/","parent":{"default":"/"},"additional_properties":{"original":{"_id":"/news","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio news, Cleveland Ohio news Ohio local news, Ohio breaking news, latest news, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Cleveland & Ohio Local News","headline":"Ohio Real-Time News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/news"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/news/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"News","order":{"toprail":1001,"ellipsis":1014,"native-app-news":1001,"native-app-test":1001,"photocenter":1001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","native-app-test":"/","photocenter":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-app-test":["/"],"photocenter":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section"}},"_website_section_id":"cleveland./news"},"website_url":"/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html"}},"additional_properties":{"has_published_copy":true},"publish_date":"2023-01-05T15:00:01.640Z","canonical_url":"/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html","publishing":{"scheduled_operations":{"publish_edition":[],"unpublish_edition":[]}},"website":"cleveland","website_url":"/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html","multimedia_main":{"_id":"J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE","additional_properties":{"countryId":227,"fullSizeResizeUrl":"/resizer/3iGlxowQE-f3Q8xK_UWT7EpeeMw=/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","galleries":[],"ingestionMethod":"manual","iptc_job_identifier":"WX417","iptc_source":"FR66830 AP","iptc_title":"FRE","keywords":[""],"mime_type":"image/jpeg","originalName":"ryan vance.jpg","originalUrl":"https://cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/advancelocal/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","proxyUrl":"/resizer/3iGlxowQE-f3Q8xK_UWT7EpeeMw=/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","published":true,"resizeUrl":"/resizer/3iGlxowQE-f3Q8xK_UWT7EpeeMw=/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","restricted":false,"takenOn":"2022-08-05T17:02:17Z","thumbnailResizeUrl":"/resizer/RY6_yhi6pEvesh3AaH5ptbPEMwk=/300x0/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-advancelocal/public/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","usage_instructions":"PHOTO BY PAUL VERNON, LEFT, AND LM OTERO, RIGHT","version":0,"template_id":7,"_id":"PDZH22VGMVHUPC33UOYJ57Q3SA"},"address":{"country_name":"USA"},"auth":{"1":"e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf"},"caption":"This combination of photos shows Ohio Democratic Senate candidate Rep. Tim Ryan, D-Ohio, on March 28, 2022, in Wilberforce, Ohio, left, and Republican candidate JD Vance on Aug. 5, 2022, in Dallas. (AP Photo)","copyright":"Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved","created_date":"2022-10-28T13:54:54Z","credits":{"affiliation":[{"name":"AP","type":"author"}],"by":[{"byline":"LM Otero","name":"LM Otero","type":"author"}]},"height":715,"image_type":"photograph","last_updated_date":"2022-10-28T13:54:54Z","licensable":false,"owner":{"id":"advancelocal","sponsored":false},"slug":"Election 2022 Senate Ohio","source":{"additional_properties":{"editor":"photo center"},"edit_url":"","system":"photo center"},"subtitle":"Tim Ryan JD Vance","taxonomy":{"associated_tasks":[]},"type":"image","url":"https://cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/advancelocal/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg","version":"0.10.9","width":1024,"syndication":{},"creditIPTC":"AP","country_name":"United States","resized_urls":{"large":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90","medium":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=800&smart=true&quality=90","small":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=500&smart=true&quality=90","x_small":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/J3XNGXSRXRH4THFDYYIPXGRUIE.jpg?auth=e96c53e271e8d656be4efa2b48fa70b2acb2efb5419a639ed6366c61ec1b89bf&width=180&smart=true&quality=90"}}};Fusion.globalContentConfig={"source":"article-beta-content-api","query":{"uri":"/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html","website_url":"/news/2023/01/ohios-2022-us-senate-race-shatters-spending-records.html","type":"elements","limit":3,"arc-site":"cleveland"}};Fusion.lastModified=1766050636994;Fusion.contentCache={"pennant-api":{"undefined":{"data":{"piano-onoff":true,"google-one-tap-onoff":false,"sophi-onoff":true,"sophi-variants-onoff":true,"self-service":true,"show-poll-results":true,"subscribe-with-google-onoff":true,"userdiagnosticsonoff":false,"auth0-bcsessionid-onoff":false,"trackonomics-amp-wrapper-onoff":true,"gallery-slideshow-onoff":true,"share-with-a-friend-onoff":false,"widgetmaker-onoff":true,"amp-newsletter-signup-onoff":false,"enewspaper-toprail-button-onoff":true,"toprail-button-marketcolor":true,"account-landing-page-onoff":true,"piano-datadog-onoff":true,"exco-video-ads-in-article":true,"recaptcha-datadog-onoff":true,"cdpsegmentevent-datadog-onoff":false,"related-articles":true,"sophi-dynamic-paywall-onoff":true,"auth0-refresh-tokens-onoff":false,"toprail-button-text-cyber":false,"related-articles-blueconic":false,"sticky-toprail":true,"subscriber-exclusive-label-onoff":false,"newspaperscom-archives-onoff":true,"newspaperscom-sparkle-onoff":false,"custom-alerts-sample-button-onoff":true,"next-best-action-interval-served-onoff":false,"next-best-action-onoff":true,"recommended-articles-slider":false,"blueconic-recommendations-datadog-onoff":true,"sidelines-promo-banner-on-off":false,"subscriber-exclusive-onoff":true,"live-indicator":true,"toprail-button-text-dollar-deal":false,"queryly-ask-onoff":false,"affiliate-brand-label-onoff":false,"rollcall-blueconic-segments-datadog-onoff":false,"_id":"ba63b70bd596a99138555e0c87c312659e5b94aa064e0c6c408f171754347005"},"expires":1766050693587,"lastModified":1765226983000}},"admiral-install-api":{"{\"propertyID\":\"A-5C9E70EBD9D905257F625AAB-2\"}":{"data":{"script":"!(function(b,_name){b[_name]=b[_name]||function n(){(n.q=n.q||[]).push(arguments)},b[_name].v=b[_name].v||2,b[_name].s=\"3\";!(function(b,n,v,U,Q){function V(U,Q){try{V=b.localStorage,(U=JSON.parse(V[decodeURI(decodeURI('g%25%36%35%74I%25%37%34%256%35%6d'))](v)).lgk||[])&&(Q=b[n].pubads())&&U.forEach((function(b){b&&b[0]&&Q.setTargeting(b[0],b[1]||\"\")}))}catch(q){}var V}try{(Q=b[n]=b[n]||{}).cmd=Q.cmd||[],typeof Q.pubads===U?V():typeof Q.cmd.unshift===U?Q.cmd.unshift(V):Q.cmd.push(V)}catch(q){}})(window,decodeURI(decodeURI('%25%36%37o%25%36%66%67l%2565%74a%256%37')),\"_a\"+decodeURI(decodeURI(\"%2551%25%35%33%25301%51%257%61lF%25%34%65%257%61%42%254%36%51%25%36b%25%351%253%35%52%254%34%256b%77%4e%54%49%25%33%31N%25%33%30%255%39%32M%25%36%61V%25%34%32%255%31U%25%349t%4d%2567\")),\"function\");;})(window,decodeURI(decodeURI('a%256%34%25%36%64%256%39r%2561l')));!(function(b,n,v,U,Q,V,q,z,s,f,K,l,P,O,I,G,H,j,p,e,d,k,y,C,Z){function m(v,V){navigator.onLine&&e&&(e=!1,(V=(function(b,n,v){if(!G)return!1;for(n=(b=G.getEntriesByType(\"resource\")).length;v=b[--n];)if(!v.deliveryType&&v.transferSize>300&&v.fetchStart>H)return!0;return!1})())||(Z=8),!d&&p&&(Z=16),!d&&!V||(function(v,V,q){if(!/bot|spider|headlesschrome|java\\//i.test(navigator.userAgent||\"\")&&(new(function(){v=(function h(e,t,r,n){if(!e||(function e(r,n,i,o){for(o=0;r&&o<r.length;o+=2)o>0&&(r[o+1]||[]).unshift(i),i=(n=t[r[o]])&&n(e,r[o+1]||[]);return i})(e))return r.apply(this,n||[])}([0,[[[1,[[3,[],2,[\"/digitalsubscription\"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,[\"/insider\"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,[\"/subscribe\"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,[\"/supporter\"]]]],[1,[[3,[],2,[\"/contributor\"]]]],[4,[[[1,[[6,[\"%25%361%64%256%64%2562%25%365%256%65%2565%25%36%36%69t%25%373\"],5,[\"\"]]]]]]],[1,[[6,[\"%25%363a%6c%25%36%35%255%66r%65%2573%25%375%6c%74%257%33\"],5,[\"true\"]]]]]]],[function c(e,t){for(var r=t[0]&&t[0].length>0,n=0;r&&n<t[0].length;n++)r=e(t[0][n]);return r},function a(e,t){return!e(t[0])},function l(e,t,r,n){return r=t[0]||\"\",(n=t[1]||\"\")?0===r.indexOf(n):!!r},function p(e,t,r){return\"/\"+(document.location.pathname||\"\").replace(/^\\/+|\\/+$/,\"\")},function c(e,t){for(var r=t[0]&&t[0].length>0,n=0;r&&n<t[0].length;n++)r=e(t[0][n]);return r},function u(e,t,r,n){return r=t[0]||\"\",(n=t[1]||\"\")?-1!==r.indexOf(n):!!r},function f(e,t,r){return(r=(document.cookie||\"\").match(new RegExp(\"(^|;\\\\s*)\"+decodeURI(decodeURI(t[0]))+\"\\\\s*=\\\\s*([^;]+)\")))?r[2]:void 0}],function(d,c,e,f,i,m,y){e=d.createElement(\"div\");e.innerHTML=\"<div class=\\\"DCDOr\\\"><div class=\\\"eRIqgq a__s1p0xe8r-0\\\"><div class=\\\"ezkXGa a__s1p0xe8r-0\\\"><div class=\\\"fkhZMO\\\"><h3 class=\\\"kMGqeO\\\">Your experience is important to us.<\\/h3><div class=\\\"eFEjHN\\\">For optimal functionality on cleveland.com, please disable your ad blocker before continuing.\\n<div id=\\\"admLoginLink\\\" style=\\\"position:relative;top:86px;\\\"><a href=\\\"https://auth0.cleveland.com/u/login?adm_src=admiral\\\" style=\\\"color:#333333;text-decoration:underline;font-size:12px;font-weight: bold;font-family: Helvetica;\\\">Already a Subscriber? Log In<\\/a><\\/div><\\/div><button data-5mfku-0 data-s9pexq4cgx=\\\"https://my.g%65%74adm%69r%61l.com/instructions\\\" class=\\\"ilwEwD a__s1p0xe8r-1\\\">Disable my adblocker<\\/button><\\/div><div class=\\\"jozuUb\\\"><img src=\\\"https://i.imgur.com/4hqNGzW.png\\\" class=\\\"hgqALM\\\"><\\/img><\\/div><\\/div><\\/div><div class=\\\"idHFrh\\\"><span class=\\\"bRORkN\\\"><a href=\\\"https://%67e%74%61dmira%6c.typeform.com/to/s8M2nY5H\\\" target=\\\"_blank\\\" class=\\\"dWdYmI\\\">Contact support<\\/a><\\/span><span class=\\\"bRORkN\\\">|<\\/span><span class=\\\"bRORkN\\\"><a href=\\\"https://g%65%74%61%64%6d%69%72%61l.com/pb/\\\" target=\\\"_blank\\\" class=\\\"dWdYmI\\\">We're using <img src=\\\"https://pubimgs.net/412d3543394537304542443944393035323537463632354141422d32_logo.svg\\\" class=\\\"ggJJaU\\\"><\\/img><\\/a><\\/span><\\/div><\\/div>\";f=[\"click\",function(e){var t=e.currentTarget.getAttribute(\"data-s9pexq4cgx\"),r=e.currentTarget.parentElement,n=document.createElement(\"iframe\");n.src=t,n.style=\"margin: 36px 0;outline: 0;border: 0;width: 100%;height: 400px;\",r.replaceWith(n);var i=function(e){var t=e.data,o=t.goBack,c=t.blockerDisabled;o?(n.replaceWith(r),window.removeEventListener(\"message\",i)):c&&window.location.reload()};window.addEventListener(\"message\",i)}];for (i=0;i<f.length;i+=2){(m=e.querySelector('[data-5mfku-'+i+']'))&&m.addEventListener(f[i],f[i+1])}y=d.createElement(\"style\");y[c](d.createTextNode(\".DCDOr{all:initial;position:fixed;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;left:0;font-family:Arial;overflow:auto;background-color:rgba(255,255,255,1);z-index:2147483647;}.DCDOr .a__s1p0xe8r-0{width:100%;height:100%;margin:0 auto;}.DCDOr .a__s1p0xe8r-1{cursor:pointer;border:none;font-weight:700;}.eRIqgq{max-width:740px;position:relative;}.ezkXGa{box-sizing:border-box;display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-flex-direction:column;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;-webkit-align-items:flex-start;-webkit-box-align:flex-start;-ms-flex-align:flex-start;align-items:flex-start;-webkit-box-pack:center;-webkit-justify-content:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;}.fkhZMO{display:inline-block;max-width:700px;width:100%;margin-bottom:48px;padding-bottom:48px;border-bottom:1px solid #121e401f;color:rgba(24,33,57,1);}.idHFrh{position:fixed;bottom:0;height:40px;width:100%;text-align:center;line-height:40px;font-size:13px;color:rgba(12,44,91,1);background-color:rgba(24,33,57,0.05);}.jozuUb{display:block;}.hgqALM{max-width:150px;max-height:150px;}.ggJJaU{height:15px;vertical-align:middle;}.kMGqeO{box-sizing:border-box;text-align:left;margin:0 0 5px;font-size:24px;line-height:28px;font-weight:500;}.eFEjHN{box-sizing:border-box;text-align:left;margin:0 0 15px;font-size:14px;line-height:22px;}.bRORkN{display:inline-block;margin-right:5px;line-height:40px;}.dWdYmI{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;color:rgba(12,44,91,1);}.ilwEwD{width:100%;height:33px;background-color:rgba(42,42,42,1);color:rgba(244,244,246,1);border-radius:3px;margin-bottom:24px;}\"));d.body[c](y);d.body[c](e);window[decodeURI(decodeURI('%25%35fa%2564m%255%33%74%25%361%74%2569cEn%25%36%37%2561%2567e%25%35%32%65%6e%64%2565r%65%25%36%34'))]=!0;return {\"candidates\":[{\"batchID\":\"659c6815ef8207d1326e80f3\",\"candidateID\":\"659c6815ef8207d1326e80f2\",\"groups\":[\"purpose:failsafe\"],\"payload\":{\"name\":\"Failsafe\"},\"payloadType\":\"template\",\"simpleCriteria\":{},\"triggers\":[{\"type\":\"adblockerDisabled\"}],\"tsUpdated\":1749138818.239}]}},[document,\"appendChild\"]))}),!f++)){V=n.sessionStorage;try{q=JSON.parse(V[U(U(K))]).slice(-4)}catch(z){q=[]}q.push([Q(),{p:\"\"+n.location,r:\"\"+b.referrer,cs:v,t:1,fc:Z}]),V[U(U(K))]=JSON.stringify(q)}})())}G=n.performance,p=n.fetch,P=U(U('%256%31d%256%64%25%36%39%25%37%32%25%361%25%36c')),O=U(U('%25%361dm%257%32%256cLoa%64%25%36%35%2564')),e=!p,(function o(U,V,f,K,y,C){function Z(){n[O]&&v(I),C||n[P]&&n[P].a&&\"function\"==typeof n[P].a.ready||u()}function u(b){f&&y.removeChild(f),v(I),b&&!1===b.isTrusted||V>=4?(n.setTimeout(m,d!==undefined||e?0:Math.max(4e3-(Q()-j),Math.max(2e3-((G&&G.now())-H),0))),e=!0):o(V<2?U:l,++V)}(C=U===l)&&3===V&&p(U).then((function(b){b.ok?b.text().then((function(b){b.includes(O)?v(I):u({})}),(function(b){u({})})):u({})}),(function(b){u({})})),f=b.createElement(q),K=b[s](q)[0],y=K.parentNode,f.async=1,f.src=U,1==V&&p&&(j=Q(),p((function(v,U,Q,V,q,z,f,K){for(U=(v=b[s](\"link\")).length,V=(n.origin||\"\").length||1;V&&(Q=v[--U]);)if(q=(Q.href||\"\").substring(0,V),f=0===(Q.type||\"\").indexOf(\"image/\"),K=\"icon\"===Q.rel||(Q.rel||\"\").indexOf(\" icon\")>=0,(f||K)&&(\"/\"===q[0]||q===n.origin)&&(z=Q.href,f&&K))return Q.href;return z||\"/favicon.ico\"})(),{mode:\"no-cors\",credentials:\"omit\",cache:\"no-cache\"}).then((function(){d=!0,m()}),(function(b){d=!1}))),k=0,1===V&&k?k(f,(function(b){b||Z()})):f[z]&&(I=n.setTimeout(Z,C?3e4:6e3),f[z](\"error\",u),f[z](\"load\",Z)),y.insertBefore(f,K)})(\"https://cardmethod.com/build/jecdpirqtjtz.index.js\",0),H=G&&G.now()})(document,window,clearTimeout,decodeURI,Date.now,0,\"script\",\"addEventListener\",\"getElementsByTagName\",0,'%256%31%66sv%256%39s%25%369t%2573',\"https://succeedscene.com/customads/custom_ads.js\");","_id":"027faf7ee22e63e52140ec009e2fdf3c4fec78800d27551c8fc7689dbd077b1e"},"expires":1766054115475,"lastModified":1766050515263}},"navigation":{"{\"hierarchy\":\"toprail\",\"site\":\"cleveland\"}":{"data":{"_website":"cleveland","_id":"/","name":"cleveland.com","node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/news","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland & Ohio latest news. Find photos and videos, comment on the news, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio news, Cleveland Ohio news Ohio local news, Ohio breaking news, latest news, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Cleveland & Ohio Local News","headline":"Ohio Real-Time News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/news"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/news/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"News","order":{"toprail":1001,"ellipsis":1018,"native-app-news":1001,"native-app-test":1001,"photocenter":1001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","native-app-test":"/","photocenter":"/","subnav-tv":null},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-app-test":["/"],"photocenter":["/"],"subnav-tv":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/metro","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest breaking local news for Cleveland and Northeast Ohio from The Plain Dealer and cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"cleveland plain dealer, cleveland news, cleveland breaking news, northeast ohio news, plain dealer news, cleveland metro news, plain dealer metro section, greater cleveland news","site_title":"Metro News","headline":"Metro News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/metro"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Metro","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Metro","order":{"toprail":2001,"ellipsis":2012},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-akron_news","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Support cleveland.com","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/subscribe/","parent":{"toprail":"/news","subscriptions":"/"},"order":{"toprail":2002,"subscriptions":1001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/plaindealer","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Cleveland news online from The Plain Dealer, Ohio's largest newspaper. Get local business, sports, entertainment news and more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland Plain Dealer, Plain Dealer, Cleveland newspaper, Ohio newspaper, Cleveland Oh newspaper, Cleveland local news, Online newspaper, US newspaper, local newspaper","site_title":"Cleveland Plain Dealer | Cleveland, Ohio Newspaper","headline":"The Plain Dealer","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/plaindealer"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/plaindealer/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"The Plain Dealer","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"The Plain Dealer","order":{"toprail":2003,"ellipsis":2019},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/healthfit","site":{"site_description":"Get breaking Cleveland and Northeast Ohio health and fitness and medical consumer news. Find tips, articles and information on healthy living at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio health, health and fitness, health and fitness tips, health news, medical consumer news, health articles, health information, healthy living","site_title":"Health and Fitness | Ohio Medical Consumer News","headline":"Health & Fitness","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/healthfit"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/healthfit/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Health & Medical","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Health & Fitness","order":{"toprail":2004,"ellipsis":2009},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/crime","site":{"site_description":"Get real-time Northeast Ohio crime news, listen to police blotters updates and find out where your neighborhood ranks in our crime rate databases.","site_keywords":"Cleveland crime, Cleveland police, Ohio crime, crime news, police blotter, police scanner, ohio jails, ohio murders, Cleveland murders, Cleveland homicide, Cleveland gangs","site_title":"Cleveland, OH Crime & Police News with The Plain Dealer","headline":"Crime","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/crime"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/crime/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Crime","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Crime","order":{"toprail":2005,"ellipsis":2013},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/datacentral","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland, Ohio census data & demographics. Find population, crime, sports, political and other interesting statistics at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"cleveland ohio statistics and demographics, cleveland statistics and demographics, ohio statistics, ohio demographics, cleveland statistics, cleveland census, cleveland demographics, crime statistics, population statistics, interesting statistics, sports statistics, political statistics, data central","site_title":"Cleveland Ohio Statistics & Demographics | Data Central","headline":"Data Central","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/datacentral"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/datacentral/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Data Central","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Data Central","order":{"toprail":2006,"ellipsis":2014},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/columns","site":{"site_description":"Get list of The Plain Dealer columnists and opinion pages for news, sports, entertainment, arts, business and more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"plain dealer columnists, opinion page, news columnist, sports columnist, entertainment columnist","site_title":"The Plain Dealer Columnists and Opinion Pages","headline":"Columnists","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/columns"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/columns/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Columnists","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Columnists","order":{"toprail":2007,"ellipsis":2017},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/court-justice","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest updates on news about Cleveland’s justice system and court houses.","site_keywords":"cleveland courthouse news, cleveland justice system, northeast ohio courts, cleveland legal news","site_title":"Court & Justice - legal news, courthouse updates and more","headline":"Courts and Justice","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/court-justice"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/court-justice/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Courts","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Courts and Justice","order":{"toprail":2008,"ellipsis":2022},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/nation","site":{"site_description":"Find the latest breaking US national news. Get top U.S. news stories on politics, business, crime & more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"US news, U.S. news, national news, politics news, breaking news, business news, latest news, top news, crime news, news headlines","site_title":"US News | Breaking National News","headline":"U.S. News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/nation"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/nation/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Nation","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"U.S. News","order":{"toprail":2009,"ellipsis":2010},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/world","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest breaking world news covering the current international top stories from cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"world news, international news, global news, latest world news, foreign news, breaking news, latest news, current news, top stories","site_title":"World News | Breaking International & Foreign News","headline":"World News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/world"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/world/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"World","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"World News","order":{"toprail":2010,"ellipsis":2018},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/specialreports","site":{"site_description":"Special Reports","site_keywords":null,"site_title":"Special Reports","headline":"Special Reports","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/specialreports"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Special Reports","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Special Reports","order":{"toprail":2011},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/a-greater-cleveland","site":{"site_description":"A community-wide effort to make a difference in the lives of children living in poverty, to help remove the barriers they face that those in the suburbs do not, on cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"poverty, opportunity, greater cleveland, children, community","site_title":"A Greater Cleveland","headline":"A Greater Cleveland","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/a-greater-cleveland"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/a-greater-cleveland/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"A Greater Cleveland","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"A Greater Cleveland","order":{"toprail":3001,"ellipsis":2023},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/specialreports","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/specialreports"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-a_critical_choice_nursing_home_care","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"A Critical Choice: Nursing home care","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/page/a_critical_choice_plain_dealer_1.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-at_any_court_cost","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"At Any (Court) Cost","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/page/court_costs_in_northeast_ohio.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-clevelands_bike_life","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Cleveland’s Bike Life","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/page/clevelands_bike_life.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3004},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-dear_cleveland","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Dear Cleveland","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/page/dear_cleveland.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3005},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-heroins_human_toll","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Heroin's Human Toll","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/crime/page/heroin.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3006},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-justice_for_all_bail_reform","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Justice for All: Bail reform","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/page/justice_for_all_bail_reform_in.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3007},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/knowtherx","site":{"site_description":"Addressing the opioid epidemic: Comprehensive reference guide for opioid addiction and recovery resources on cleveland.com.","site_keywords":null,"site_title":"KnowTheRx","headline":"KnowTheRx","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/knowtherx"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/knowtherx/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Know the RX: Opioid addiction resources","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Know the RX","order":{"toprail":3008,"ellipsis":2011},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/specialreports","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/specialreports"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/out-of-line","site":{"site_description":"cleveland.com takes an in-depth look gerrymandering Ohio and the challenges of redistricting.","site_keywords":"gerrymandering, ohio redistricting, elections, voting, news","site_title":"Out of Line: Gerrymandering in Ohio","headline":"Out of Line: Gerrymandering in Ohio","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/out-of-line"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/out-of-line/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Out of Line: Gerrymandering in Ohio","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Out of Line: Gerrymandering in Ohio","order":{"toprail":3009,"ellipsis":2025},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/specialreports","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/specialreports"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-recovering_hope","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Recovering Hope","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/metro/page/recovering_hope.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3010},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-remaking_the_q","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Remaking The Q","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/cavs/page/remaking_the_q.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3011},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-stolen_in_the_suburbs","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Stolen in the Suburbs","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/crime/page/stolen_in_the_suburbs_auto_the.html","parent":{"toprail":"/specialreports"},"order":{"toprail":3012},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/city-club","site":{"site_description":"News and information about the City Club of Cleveland, covering vital conversations and civil, civic dialogue in Cleveland and the State of Ohio.","site_keywords":"Cleveland City Club, City Club of Cleveland","site_title":"The City Club of Cleveland","headline":"The City Club of Cleveland","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/city-club"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/city-club/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"City Club of Cleveland","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"City Club of Cleveland","order":{"toprail":2012,"ellipsis":2021},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/news","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/news","/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/weather","site":{"site_description":"Weather","site_keywords":null,"site_title":"Cleveland, OH Weather Forecast, Radar & News","headline":"Weather","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/weather"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/weather/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Weather","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Weather","order":{"ellipsis":2020,"toprail":1002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/podcasts","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/podcasts/","tracking_node":null,"alias_ids":["/podcasts"],"default_content":null},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Get the latest podcasts about the Cleveland Browns, Cavaliers, Indians and Ohio State Buckeyes on cleveland.com","headline":"Podcasts","site_keywords":"podcasts, Cleveland Indians, Cleveland Cavaliers, Cleveland Browns, Ohio State Buckeyes","site_title":"Podcasts"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Podcasts","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Podcasts","order":{"ellipsis":2032,"toprail":1003,"native-app-news":1003},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/news","hamburger-menu":"/","toprail":"/","native-app-news":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/news"],"hamburger-menu":[],"toprail":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/politics","site":{"site_description":"Get United States national politics news and election results.","site_keywords":"us politics,presidential race,united states president,election results, ohio election results, united states congress,politics news","site_title":"National Politics: U.S. political news, blogs and election results","headline":"National Politics","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/politics"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/politics/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Politics & Elections","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"National Politics","order":{"toprail":1004,"ellipsis":1024,"subnav-election":1005},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":null,"hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-election":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":[],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-election":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/open","site":{"site_description":"Get Ohio political news, views and blogs from the Plain Dealer. Find Ohio candidates and politicians news, election results and more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"ohio politics, political news, political views, political blogs","site_title":"Ohio Politics & Election News","headline":"Ohio Politics","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/open"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/open/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"State Politics","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Ohio Politics","order":{"toprail":2001,"ellipsis":2002,"native-app-news":1010,"subnav-election":1004},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/politics","ellipsis":"/politics","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-election":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/politics"],"ellipsis":["/politics"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-election":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-national_politics_elections","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"National Politics & Elections","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/politics/","parent":{"toprail":"/politics"},"order":{"toprail":2002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/cityhall","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Cleveland, Ohio political and government news from inside city hall with Plain Dealer reporter Thomas Ott cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"cleveland city hall, cleveland ohio local news, cleveland government, cleveland mayor, cleveland politics, political news, city council news","site_title":"Inside Cleveland City Hall","headline":"Inside Cleveland City Hall","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/cityhall"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/cityhall/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Cleveland City Hall","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Cleveland City Hall","order":{"toprail":2003,"ellipsis":2003},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/politics","ellipsis":"/politics","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/politics"],"ellipsis":["/politics"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/cuyahoga-county","site":{"site_description":"Get updates on Cuyahoga County Ohio politics and government transition to a county executive government at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cuyahoga county politics, cuyahoga county government, cuyahoga county commissioners, cuyahoga county ohio","site_title":"Cuyahoga County Politics & Government | Cuyahoga County Insider","headline":"Cuyahoga County Insider","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/cuyahoga-county"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/cuyahoga-county/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Cuyahoga County Insider","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Cuyahoga County Insider","order":{"toprail":2004,"ellipsis":2004},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/politics","ellipsis":"/politics","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/politics"],"ellipsis":["/politics"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-out_of_line_gerrymandering_in_ohio","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Out of Line: Gerrymandering in Ohio","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/out-of-line/","parent":{"toprail":"/politics"},"order":{"toprail":2005},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-special_report_ohio_matters","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Special Report: Ohio Matters","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/politics/page/ohio_matters_redesign_politica.html","parent":{"toprail":"/politics"},"order":{"toprail":2006},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/community","site":{"site_description":"Ohio breaking news, events, businesses, classifieds, sports, photos, videos and more. Comment on the news and join forum at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Northeast Ohio Community News","headline":"Community","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/community"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/community/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Local News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Community News","order":{"toprail":1005,"ellipsis":1028,"footer":5006,"native-app-news":1013},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"footer":["/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/akron","site":{"site_description":"Get City of Akron, Ohio breaking news, events, businesses, classifieds, sports, photos, videos and more. Comment on the news and join forum at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"akron ohio, city of akron ohio, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Akron, Ohio Local News","headline":"Akron","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/akron"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/akron/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Akron","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Akron","order":{"ellipsis":2002,"toprail":2001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/community","ellipsis":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/community"],"ellipsis":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/brunswicksun","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/brunswicksun/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/brunswicksun"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Brunswick Sun - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Brunswick, Brunswick Hills and Hinckley Township","headline":"Brunswick Sun","site_keywords":"Brunswick OH news, Brunswick Hills OH news, Hinckley OH news","site_title":"Brunswick Sun"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Brunswick Sun","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Brunswick Sun","order":{"ellipsis":1051,"toprail":2002},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/chagrinsolonsun","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/chagrinsolonsun/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/chagrinsolonsun"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Chagrin Solon Sun - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Chagrin Falls, Solon, Pepper Pike, Orange, Moreland Hills and Hunting Valley","headline":"Chagrin Solon Sun","site_keywords":"Chagrin Falls OH news, Solon OH news, Pepper Pike OH news, Orange OH news, Moreland Hills OH news, Hunting Valley OH news","site_title":"Chagrin Solon Sun"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Chagrin Solon Sun","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Chagrin Solon Sun","order":{"ellipsis":1052,"toprail":2003},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/medinasun","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/medinasun/","tracking_node":null,"alias_ids":["/medinasun"],"default_content":null},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Medina Sun - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Medina and Medina Township","headline":"Medina Sun","site_keywords":"Medina OH news, Medina Township OH news","site_title":"Medina Sun"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Medina Sun","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Medina Sun","order":{"ellipsis":2029,"toprail":2004},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/news","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/news"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/newssun","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/newssun/","tracking_node":null,"alias_ids":["/newssun"],"default_content":null},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"News Sun - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Berea, Brook Park and Middleburg Heights","headline":"News Sun","site_keywords":"Berea OH news, Brook Park OH news, Middleburg Heights OH news","site_title":"News Sun"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"News Sun","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"News Sun","order":{"ellipsis":2030,"toprail":2005},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/news","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/news"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/parmasunpost","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/parmasunpost/","tracking_node":null,"alias_ids":["/parmasunpost"],"default_content":null},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Parma Sun Post - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Parma, Parma Heights, Seven Hills, Independence and Brooklyn","headline":"Parma Sun Post","site_keywords":"Parma OH news, Parma Heights OH news, Seven Hills OH news, Independence OH news, Brooklyn OH news","site_title":"Parma Sun Post"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Parma Sun Post","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Parma Sun Post","order":{"ellipsis":2031,"toprail":2006},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/news","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/news"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sunmessenger","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunmessenger/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/sunmessenger"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Sin Messenger - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Gates Mills, Highland Heights, Lyndhurst, Mayfield Heights, Mayfield Village, Richmond Heights and South Euclid","headline":"Sun Messenger","site_keywords":"Gates Mills OH news,, Highland Heights OH news,, Lyndhurst OH news,, Mayfield Heights OH news,, Mayfield Village OH news,, Richmond Heights OH news, South Euclid OH news","site_title":"Sun Messenger"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Sun Messenger","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sun Messenger","order":{"ellipsis":1047,"toprail":2007},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sunnews","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunnews/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/sunnews"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Sun News - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Greater Cleveland suburbs","headline":"Sun News","site_keywords":"Greater Cleveland news, Northeast Ohio news, Cleveland OH suburban news","site_title":"Sun News"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Sun News","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sun News","order":{"ellipsis":1048,"toprail":2008},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sunpress","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunpress/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/sunpress"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Sun Press - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Beachwood, Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights and University Heights","headline":"Sun Press","site_keywords":"Beachwood OH news, Cleveland Heights OH news, Shaker Heights OH news, University Heights OH news","site_title":"Sun Press"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Sun Press","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sun Press","order":{"ellipsis":1050,"toprail":2009},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sunpostherald","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunpostherald/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/sunpostherald"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Sun Post Herald - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Lakewood, Fairview Park, North Olmsted, Olmsted Falls and Olmsted Township","headline":"Sun Post Herald","site_keywords":"Lakewood OH news, Fairview Park OH news, North Olmsted OH news, Olmsted Falls OH news, Olmsted Township OH news","site_title":"Sun Post Herald"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Sun Post Herald","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sun Post Herald","order":{"ellipsis":1049,"toprail":2010},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sunsentinel","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunsentinel/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/sunsentinel"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Sun Sentinel - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Avon, Avon Lake and North Ridgeville","headline":"Sun Sentinel","site_keywords":"Avon OH news, Avon Lake OH news, North Ridgeville OH news","site_title":"Sun Sentinel"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Sun Sentinel","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sun Sentinel","order":{"ellipsis":1053,"toprail":2011},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sunstarcourier","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunstarcourier/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/sunstarcourier"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"Sun Star Courier - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Strongsville, North Royalton, Broadview Heights and Brecksville","headline":"Sun Star Courier","site_keywords":"Strongsville OH news, North Royalton OH news, Broadview Heights OH news, Brecksville OH news","site_title":"Sun Star Courier"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"Sun Star Courier","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sun Star Courier","order":{"ellipsis":1054,"toprail":2012},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/westshoresun","_admin":{"commercial_node":"","url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/westshoresun/","tracking_node":"","alias_ids":["/westshoresun"],"default_content":""},"site":{"site_section":"News","site_description":"West Shore Sun - News, sports, business, entertainment, living and blogs covering Bay Village, Rocky River and Westlake","headline":"West Shore Sun","site_keywords":"Bay Village OH news, Rocky River OH news, Westlake OH news","site_title":"West Shore Sun"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_title":"West Shore Sun","nav_display":"true"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"West Shore Sun","order":{"ellipsis":1056,"toprail":2013},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/community","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/community"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-more_east_side","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"More East Side","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunnews/2013/01/read_the_news_from_east_and_so.html","parent":{"toprail":"/community"},"order":{"toprail":2014},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-more_west_side","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"More West Side","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/sunnews/2013/01/read_the_news_from_west_and_so.html","parent":{"toprail":"/community"},"order":{"toprail":2015},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/opinion","site":{"site_description":"Opinions, Editorials, Letters and Columns from The Plain Dealer.","site_keywords":"opinion, editorials, plain dealer, letters to the editor, columns, Cleveland, Ohio columnists","site_title":"Opinions, Editorials, Letters and Columns from The Plain Dealer","headline":"Opinion","site_section":"Opinion"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/opinion"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Opinion","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Opinion","order":{"toprail":1006,"ellipsis":1033,"native-app-news":1011},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/letters","site":{"site_description":"Plain Dealer and cleveland.com readers submit their letters on the important news topics.","site_keywords":"letters to the editor, plain dealer letters, opinion letters, reader opinions","site_title":"Letters to the editor","headline":"Letters Unlimited","site_section":"Opinion"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/letters"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/letters/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Letters to the Editor","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Letters to the Editor","order":{"toprail":2001,"ellipsis":2001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/opinion","ellipsis":"/opinion","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/opinion"],"ellipsis":["/opinion"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/darcy","site":{"site_description":"Get editorial, political and local Cleveland cartoons by Jeff Darcy of The Plain Dealer.","site_keywords":"cleveland cartoons, plain dealer editorial, political cartoons, jeff darcy","site_title":"Editorial and Political Cartoons by Jeff Darcy of The Plain Dealer","headline":"Jeff Darcy’s Editorial Cartoons","site_section":"Opinion"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/darcy"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/darcy/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Jeff Darcy's Cartoons","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Jeff Darcy’s Editorial Cartoons","order":{"toprail":2002,"ellipsis":2002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/opinion","ellipsis":"/opinion","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/opinion"],"ellipsis":["/opinion"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-4WJ4MS5OINCMNHTQ3WRCEEVAKU","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Editorials","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/editorial/","parent":{"toprail":"/opinion"},"order":{"toprail":2003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-more_columnists","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"More columnists","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/columns/","parent":{"toprail":"/opinion"},"order":{"toprail":2004},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/business","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest business news. Find international, small and Cleveland OH local business news articles about economy and finance along with up to date financial market coverage from cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"business news, business economics finance, local business news, small business news, business news articles","site_title":"Cleveland, OH Business Center | Resources, Articles, Blogs & Listings","headline":"Cleveland Business News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/business"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/business/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Business","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Business","order":{"toprail":1007,"ellipsis":1034,"native-app-news":1012},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/ohio-utilities","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest news on Ohio public utilities, energy, power plant, natural gas, electricity and alternative energy news. Comment on the news and join forums at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"ohio utilities, ohio public utilities, ohio power, ohio energy, ohio natural gas, ohio electric, ohio power plants, energy news","site_title":"Ohio Power & Utilities News","headline":"Ohio Utilities and Energy","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/ohio-utilities"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/ohio-utilities/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Energy","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Energy","order":{"toprail":2002,"ellipsis":2001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/business","ellipsis":"/business","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/business"],"ellipsis":["/business"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/consumeraffairs","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland and Ohio news about consumer affairs, complaints, problems, laws and legislation, scams and more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"consumer affairs, consumer news, consumer blog","site_title":"Consumer Affairs with Sheryl Harris | Consumer News","headline":"Consumer Affairs","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/consumeraffairs"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/consumeraffairs/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Consumer Affairs","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Consumer Affairs","order":{"toprail":2003,"ellipsis":2002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/business","ellipsis":"/business","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/business"],"ellipsis":["/business"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/personalfinance","site":{"site_description":"Get personal finance and money management tips. Find financial and money news that affects Ohioans at clevelend.com.","site_keywords":"personal finance, financial news, money management, money news","site_title":"Personal Finance | Money Management Guide","headline":"Personal Finance","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/personalfinance"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/personalfinance/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Personal Finance","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Personal Finance","order":{"toprail":2004,"ellipsis":2003},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/business","ellipsis":"/business","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/business"],"ellipsis":["/business"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/top-workplaces","site":{"site_description":"Read about the top workplaces in Cleveland and Northeast, Ohio at cleveland.com","site_keywords":"Cleveland, OH top workplaces, best places to work in Northeast Ohio, ohio top jobs, ohio best jobs, ohio top companies, ohio employers, ohio top places to work,workplace dynamics","site_title":"Northeast Ohio Top Workplaces","headline":"Northeast Ohio Top Workplaces","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/top-workplaces"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/top-workplaces/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Top Workplaces","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Top Workplaces","order":{"toprail":2005,"ellipsis":2004},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/business","ellipsis":"/business","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/business"],"ellipsis":["/business"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/sports","site":{"site_description":"Get breaking news on Cleveland & Ohio high school, college and professional sports. Find scores, statistics, photos, videos and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio sports, OH sports, sports news, sports blog, sports scores, sports teams, sports results, sports statistics, sports updates, sports schedules, sports photos","site_title":"Cleveland & Ohio Sports | High School, College & Pro Sports News","headline":"Ohio Sports","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/sports"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sports/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Sports","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sports","order":{"toprail":1008,"ellipsis":1036,"native-app-news":1004,"native-apps-team-osu-bkc":1005,"native-apps-team-osu-fbc":1004,"native-apps-team-indians":1003,"native-apps-team-browns":1003,"native-apps-team-cavaliers":1003,"native-apps-team-bengals":1002,"native-app-test":1002,"photocenter":1002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","native-apps-team-osu-bkc":"/","native-apps-team-osu-fbc":"/","native-apps-team-indians":"/","native-apps-team-browns":"/","native-apps-team-cavaliers":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","native-apps-team-bengals":"/","native-app-test":"/","photocenter":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"native-apps-team-osu-bkc":["/"],"native-apps-team-osu-fbc":["/"],"native-apps-team-indians":["/"],"native-apps-team-browns":["/"],"native-apps-team-cavaliers":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-apps-team-bengals":["/"],"native-app-test":["/"],"photocenter":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/browns","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland Browns football news, schedule, stats, pictures and videos, and join fan forum discussions on cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"cleveland browns, cleveland browns schedule, cleveland browns football, cleveland browns news, cleveland browns pictures, cleveland browns roster, cleveland browns players, cleveland nfl,jimmy haslam,joe haden","site_title":"Cleveland Browns Football News - NFL Coverage","headline":"Browns","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/browns/"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/browns/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Browns","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Browns","order":{"toprail":2001,"ellipsis":2005,"native-app-news":1005,"native-apps-team-browns":1002,"native-app-test":2001,"subnav-sports":1001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","native-app-news":"/","native-apps-team-browns":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","native-app-test":"/sports","subnav-sports":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"native-app-news":["/"],"native-apps-team-browns":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-app-test":["/","/sports"],"subnav-sports":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"link-S6IZWWHDKVBQ3B63752OZMMLPY","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Browns Schedule","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/browns-schedule/","parent":{"toprail":"/browns"},"order":{"toprail":3001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-VCG4MT57OFCEHL7LIFIVVUUOWM","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Browns Rumors","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/browns-rumors/","parent":{"toprail":"/browns"},"order":{"toprail":3002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-NEEHJTHJUFEL3C5RTJD4VKKUUE","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Deshaun Watson News","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/deshaun-watson/","parent":{"toprail":"/browns"},"order":{"toprail":3003},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/guardians","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/guardians/","tracking_node":null,"alias_ids":["/guardians"],"default_content":null},"site":{"headline":"Cleveland Guardians","site_section":"Sports","site_keywords":"Cleveland Guardians, Cleveland Indians, Cleveland baseball","site_description":"Stories about the Cleveland Guardians Major League Baseball team","site_title":"Cleveland Guardians"},"navigation":{"nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link","nav_title":"Guardians"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Guardians","order":{"ellipsis":2004,"native-apps-team-indians":1002,"native-app-news":1006,"toprail":2002},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/sports","native-apps-team-indians":"/","native-app-news":"/","toprail":"/sports"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"native-apps-team-indians":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"toprail":["/sports","/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/cavs","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Cleveland Cavaliers news, scores and more. Comment on the games, see photos and videos, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland Cavaliers, cleveland cavs, NBA basketball, cleveland NBA, NBA news, cleveland basketball, cleveland cavaliers schedule, Kyrie Irving, Anderson Varejao, Dion Waiters, Byron Scott","site_title":"Cleveland Cavaliers Basketball NBA News","headline":"Cavaliers","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/cavs"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/cavs/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Cavaliers","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Cavaliers","order":{"toprail":2003,"ellipsis":2006,"native-app-news":1007,"native-apps-team-cavaliers":1002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","native-app-news":"/","native-apps-team-cavaliers":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"native-app-news":["/"],"native-apps-team-cavaliers":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/osu","site":{"site_description":"Get Ohio State Football, OSU Buckeyes and Urban Meyer news, schedules, and scores, see photos and videos, and join the discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio State football, ohio state buckeyes, ohio state buckeyes football, ohio state football schedule, ohio state university football, osu buckeyes, ohio state football pictures, ohio state football score, ohio state football news, ohio state basketball, ohio state buckeyes basketball, ohio state basketball schedule, ohio state university basketball, ohio state basketball pictures, ohio state basketball score, ohio state basketball news","site_title":"Ohio State Buckeyes Football & Basketball News","headline":"Buckeyes","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/osu"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/osu/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Ohio State","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Ohio State","order":{"toprail":2004,"ellipsis":2007,"native-app-news":1008,"native-apps-team-osu-bkc":1003,"native-apps-team-osu-fbc":1002,"subnav-sports-college":1001,"subnav-sports":1005},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","native-app-news":"/","native-apps-team-osu-bkc":"/","native-apps-team-osu-fbc":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-sports":"/","subnav-browns":null,"subnav-sports-college":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"native-app-news":["/"],"native-apps-team-osu-bkc":["/"],"native-apps-team-osu-fbc":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-sports":["/"],"subnav-browns":[],"subnav-sports-college":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"link-EWZNLYEXWZENZPNHFFKUVEX4LI","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Ohio State Buckeyes schedule","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/osu-buckeyes-schedule/","parent":{"toprail":"/osu"},"order":{"toprail":3001},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/sports/college","site":{"site_description":"Get Ohio and national college sports news, scores, rankings, standings, polls & more. Comment on the news, see photos and videos and join the forum at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"college sports, Ohio State sports, University of Akron sports, Kent State sports, college sports update, sports news, sports scores, sports pictures, sports statistics, college sports news","site_title":"Ohio College Sports | Ohio State, Kent State, University of Akron, Cleveland State, more","headline":"College Sports","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/sports/college"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sports/college/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"College","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"name":"College Sports","_website":"cleveland","parent":{"default":"/sports","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","hamburger-menu":"/sports","native-app-test":"/sports"},"ancestors":{"default":["/sports"],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"hamburger-menu":["/sports"],"native-app-test":["/","/sports"]},"inactive":false,"order":{"toprail":2005,"ellipsis":2015,"native-app-test":2003},"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sports/event-tickets","_admin":{"alias_ids":["/sports/event-tickets"],"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sports/event-tickets/"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link","nav_display":"true","nav_title":"Sports Event Tickets"},"site":{"headline":"Buy Sports Tickets","site_description":"Learn where to buy sports tickets at cleveland.com and find cheap, last-minute tickets.","site_keywords":"sports tickets, event tickets, game tickets, buy tickets, cheap tickets, last-minute tickets, sports tickets no fees","site_section":"Sports","site_title":"Sports Tickets | Where to Buy Sports Tickets"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Sports Event Tickets","order":{"ellipsis":1008,"toprail":2006},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/sports"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/sports","/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-4DJE7PCCH57UX2HMRZHUABG7DC","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Online Sports Betting","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/betting/","parent":{"toprail":"/sports"},"order":{"toprail":2007},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/highschoolsports","site":{"site_description":null,"site_keywords":null,"site_title":"High School Sports","headline":"High School Sports","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/highschoolsports"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/highschoolsports/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"High School Sports","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"High School Sports","order":{"toprail":2008,"ellipsis":2010,"native-app-test":1003},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","hamburger-menu":"/","native-app-test":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"hamburger-menu":[],"native-app-test":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/sports/columns","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland Sports articles and commentary from The Plain Dealer sports journalists like Terry Pluto, Bill Livingston & Bud Shaw at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland plain dealer sports, cleveland sports, sports articles, sports writer, sports journalist, sports report, sports columnist, Terry Pluto, Bill Livingston, Bud Sahw","site_title":"Cleveland Plain Dealer Sports Columns","headline":"Sports Columns","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/sports/columns"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/sports/columns/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Columns","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"name":"Columns","_website":"cleveland","parent":{"default":"/sports","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","hamburger-menu":"/sports"},"ancestors":{"default":["/sports"],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"hamburger-menu":["/sports"]},"inactive":false,"order":{"toprail":2009,"ellipsis":2016},"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/pluto","site":{"site_description":"Get sports blog about the Cleveland Browns, Indians, Cavaliers & Buckeyes by Terry Pluto. Comment on the blog and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Terry Pluto, cleveland sports, cleveland browns blog, cleveland indians blog, sports blog, cavaliers blog, buckeyes blog","site_title":"Cleveland, OH Sports Blog | Terry’s Talkin’ Sports","headline":"Terry Pluto’s Talkin’ Sports","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/pluto"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/pluto/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Terry Pluto","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Terry Pluto","order":{"toprail":3002,"ellipsis":3002,"subnav-browns":1004},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports/columns","ellipsis":"/sports/columns","hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-browns":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/sports/columns"],"ellipsis":["/sports","/sports/columns"],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-browns":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/monsters","site":{"site_description":"Get Cleveland Monsters AHL & Cleveland professional hockey news, schedule & more. Comment on the games, see photos and videos, and join the forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland Monsters, Cleveland monsters hockey, AHL hockey, Cleveland Hockey, Professional Hockey","site_title":"Cleveland Monsters Hockey | AHL Hockey News","headline":"Cleveland Monsters","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/monsters"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/monsters/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Monsters","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Monsters","order":{"toprail":2010,"ellipsis":2017},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-X26DBNUR312431YUJC9VQUHZW8","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Golf","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/golf/","parent":{"toprail":"/sports"},"order":{"toprail":2011},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/horseracing","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest horse racing, harness racing, and thoroughbred racing news, schedule and more from Northfield Park, Thistledown, and other race tracks in Cleveland and Northeast Ohio.","site_keywords":"cleveland horse racing, thistledown, northfield park, harness racing, thoroughbred racing","site_title":"Horse Racing News in Cleveland, OH","headline":"Horse Racing","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/horseracing"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/horseracing/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Horse Racing","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Horse Racing","order":{"toprail":2012,"ellipsis":2018},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/outdoors","site":{"site_description":"Get hunting & fishing news and reports by D'Arcy Egan. Learn about deer, duck, turkey, game hunting, bird hunting and other Cleveland & Northeast Ohio outdoor sports at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Great outdoors, ohio hunting, ohio fishing, ohio outdoors, darcy egan, fishing in cleveland ohio, ohio outdoor sports, fishing report, deer hunting, duck hunting, turkey hunting, game hunting, bird hunting","site_title":"Ohio Hunting, Fishing, Outdoor Sports | The Great Outdoors","headline":"The Great Outdoors: Hunting, Fishing and Outdoors Sports","site_section":"Sports"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/outdoors"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/outdoors/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Outdoors","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Outdoors","order":{"toprail":2013,"ellipsis":2011},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/sports","ellipsis":"/sports","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/sports","/"],"ellipsis":["/sports"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/betting","_website":"cleveland","name":"Sports Betting","inactive":false,"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/"],"native-app-news":[],"native-apps-team-indians":[],"native-apps-team-browns":[],"native-apps-team-osu-bkc":[],"native-apps-team-osu-fbc":[],"native-apps-team-cavaliers":[],"footer":[],"site-section-subnav":[],"native-apps-team-bengals":[],"native-app-test":["/"],"subnav-sports":["/"],"subnav-browns":["/"],"subnav-osu":["/"]},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/","native-app-news":null,"native-apps-team-indians":null,"native-apps-team-browns":null,"native-apps-team-osu-bkc":null,"native-apps-team-osu-fbc":null,"native-apps-team-cavaliers":null,"footer":null,"site-section-subnav":null,"native-apps-team-bengals":null,"native-app-test":"/","subnav-sports":"/","subnav-browns":"/","subnav-osu":"/"},"order":{"ellipsis":1035,"toprail":1009,"native-app-test":1005,"subnav-sports":1007,"subnav-browns":1005,"subnav-osu":1003},"_admin":{"alias_ids":["/betting"],"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/betting/"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_display":"true","nav_title":"Sports Betting"},"site":{"headline":"Ohio Sports Betting","site_description":"Online betting has never been easier! Get expert tips on daily odds, picks, promo codes and much more!","site_keywords":"Online Sports Betting Promo Codes","site_section":"Other","site_title":"Ohio Sports Betting | OH Online Sports Betting Sites"},"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"link-NFITVQ2I6ZA3JEGVNUDVGDVIV4","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Best Sportsbook Promos","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/betting/ohio-sportsbook-promos/","parent":{"default":"/betting","toprail":"/betting","subnav-sports":"/betting","subnav-osu":"/betting","subnav-browns":"/betting"},"order":{"default":2001,"toprail":2001,"subnav-sports":2001,"subnav-osu":2001,"subnav-browns":2001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-WU7HQWZRARGKBIVTEALZFQALUA","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sports Betting Guide","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/betting/guides/how-to-bet/","parent":{"default":"/betting","toprail":"/betting","subnav-sports":"/betting","subnav-browns":"/betting","subnav-osu":"/betting"},"order":{"default":2002,"toprail":2002,"subnav-sports":2002,"subnav-browns":2002,"subnav-osu":2002},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/lottery","_website":"cleveland","name":"Lottery","inactive":false,"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"]},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/","native-app-news":"/"},"_admin":{"alias_ids":["/lottery"],"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/lottery/"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_display":"true","nav_title":"Lottery"},"site":{"headline":"Ohio Lottery | Power Ball, Mega Millions Results and News - cleveland.com","site_description":"Get the latest Ohio lottery results and drawings. Search Ohio lotto daily winning numbers for Mega Millions, Power Ball, Pick 3 and others at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio lottery, OH lotto, Ohio lottery results, Ohio mega millions, Ohio Powerballl","site_section":"News","site_title":"Lottery | Exploring Cuyahoga County’s juvenile justice system"},"node_type":"section","order":{"ellipsis":1011,"toprail":1010,"native-app-news":1014},"children":[]},{"_id":"/entertainment","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Cleveland and Ohio music, movies, tv, dining news and reviews. Find local entertainment events listings, comment on the reviews, and join forum discussions at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland entertainment, Ohio entertainment, OH entertainment, entertainment news, entertainment blog, entertainment articles, Cleveland music, Cleveland movies, Cleveland dining, Cleveland TV, Cleveland events, Cleveland arts","site_title":"Cleveland & Ohio Entertainment | Music, Movies & More","headline":"Cleveland Entertainment","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/entertainment"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/entertainment/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Entertainment","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Entertainment","order":{"toprail":1011,"ellipsis":1043,"native-app-news":1009,"photocenter":1003,"subnav-music":1002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","photocenter":"/","subnav-music":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"photocenter":["/"],"subnav-music":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/food","site":{"site_description":"Get food news, recipes, dining reviews, and cooking tips for Northeast Ohio. Find an extensive collection of fine recipes and food recommendations at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland food, Cleveland recipes","site_title":"Cleveland Food and Dining","headline":"Cleveland Food & Dining","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/food"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/food/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Food/Dining","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Food & Dining","order":{"toprail":2001,"ellipsis":2003,"subnav-entertainment":1003},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-entertainment":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-entertainment":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/dining","site":{"site_description":"Your guide to fine dining and food in Cleveland and Northeast Ohio. Search and get reviews of local restaurants and bars at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland restaurants, Cleveland restaurant guide, Cleveland restaurant reviews, Cleveland bars, local restaurants, Cleveland food, Cleveland fine dining, Cleveland dining guide","site_title":"Cleveland & Northeast Ohio Restaurant Reviews & Dining Guide | Dine/Drink","headline":"Cleveland Restaurants & Dining Out","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/dining"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/dining/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Dining Guide","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Dining Guide","order":{"toprail":3001,"ellipsis":3001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/food","ellipsis":"/food","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/food"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/food"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/bars","site":{"site_description":"Guide to the best bars, clubs and lounges in Cleveland, OH at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"cleveland bars, cleveland ohio bar guide, cleveland clubs, cleveland lounges, cleveland drinking spots, cleveland night clubs, find cleveland bars","site_title":"Cleveland Top Shelf Bar Guide","headline":"Cleveland Bar News & Reviews","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/bars"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/bars/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Bars","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Bars","order":{"toprail":3002,"ellipsis":3002},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/food","ellipsis":"/food","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/food"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/food"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/cooking","site":{"site_description":"Get cooking tips, ideas, recipes and recommendations for dining in Cleveland from cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland cooking, Cleveland recipes, Cleveland dining in","site_title":"Cleveland Cooking Tips and Dining In","headline":"Cleveland Cooking and Recipes","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/cooking"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/cooking/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Cooking","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Cooking","order":{"toprail":3003,"ellipsis":4003},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/food","ellipsis":"/food","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/food"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/food"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/top-restaurants","site":{"site_description":"Get reviews of top restaurants in Cleveland and Northeast Ohio. Find places to get the best Cleveland food, the top burger, top pizza places and more at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"top cleveland restaurants, best cleveland restaurants, cleveland best food, top burgers, top pizza, restaurant reviews","site_title":"Cleveland Top Restaurants & Northeast OH Dining Guide","headline":"Cleveland Restaurant Guide","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/top-restaurants"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/top-restaurants/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Top Restaurants","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Top Restaurants","order":{"toprail":3004,"ellipsis":3004},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/food","ellipsis":"/food","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/food"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/food"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/drinks","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest drinking updates from Cleveland. From new cocktail recipes, beers or wine get it all at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland drinks, Cleveland bars","site_title":"Cleveland Drinks and Cocktails","headline":"Cleveland Drinks and Beer","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/drinks"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/drinks/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Drinks","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Drinks","order":{"toprail":3005,"ellipsis":4005},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/food","ellipsis":"/food","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/food"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/food"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/best","site":{"site_description":"Ohio’s Best: Find the best restaurants, vacation spots, companies and more in Ohio","site_keywords":"Ohio’s best foods, Ohio’s best restaurants, ohio best vacation spots, Ohio’s best companies, ohio favorite foods, ohio best thing i ever ate","site_title":"Best of Ohio: Breaking down the top places to visit, eat or work in the state","headline":"Cleveland’s Best","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/best"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/best/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Best Of","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Best Of","order":{"toprail":2002,"ellipsis":2017},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-C122RD0WHH7T1EZCAGC5T65ZQW","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Things to do","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/entertainment/2021/11/in-the-cle-newsletter-offers-lively-guide-to-things-to-do-in-greater-cleveland.html","parent":{"toprail":"/entertainment"},"order":{"toprail":2003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/movies","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Hollywood movie news and reviews including movie listings and theater show times in Cleveland, OH.","site_keywords":"Movie news, movie reviews, Hollywood movies, film festivals","site_title":"Movies News and Reviews with The Plain Dealer","headline":"Movies","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/movies"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/movies/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Movies","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Movies","order":{"toprail":2004,"ellipsis":2004},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/music","site":{"site_description":null,"site_keywords":"Cleveland music, music news, music concerts, local bands, local music, music blog","site_title":"Cleveland & Northeast Ohio Music","headline":"Music News","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/music"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/music/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Music","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Music","order":{"toprail":2005,"ellipsis":2005,"subnav-entertainment":1001},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/","subnav-entertainment":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"subnav-entertainment":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/live-entertainment","_website":"cleveland","name":"Live Entertainment","inactive":false,"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"]},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/entertainment"},"_admin":{"alias_ids":["/live-entertainment"],"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/live-entertainment/"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_display":"true","nav_title":"Live Entertainment"},"site":{"headline":"Live Entertainment","site_description":"Find live entertainment tickets and the latest news including concerts, Broadway shows, comedy shows, festivals and more.","site_keywords":"concerts, broadway shows, comedy shows, festivals, ticketmaster, stubhub, vivid seats, megaseats, ticket prices, live entertainment, live shows, music, broadway, ticket sales, ticket deals, best prices, how to buy tickets, where to buy tickets","site_section":"Life and Culture","site_title":"Live Entertainment: Concert Tickets, Broadway & Comedy Shows"},"node_type":"section","order":{"ellipsis":1009,"toprail":2006},"children":[]},{"_id":"/tv","_website":"cleveland","name":"TV Streaming","inactive":false,"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"order":{"toprail":2007,"ellipsis":2018},"_admin":{"alias_ids":["/tv"],"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/tv/"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both","nav_display":"true","nav_title":"TV Streaming"},"site":{"headline":"How to Watch Live Streaming TV and Movies Online","site_description":"Stream movies and TV live online.","site_keywords":"Cleveland TV, Cleveland TV news, Cleveland TV guide, Cleveland TV listings, TV reviews, Cleveland TV schedule, TV news, TV blogs","site_section":"Life and Culture","site_title":"Watch Live TV Streaming and Movies Online | Local Live TV Guide Tonight"},"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/books","site":{"site_description":"Book news and reviews from The Plain Dealer","site_keywords":"Karen Long, columnists, Plain Dealer, book reviews, new paperbacks, young readers, spotlight reviews, sudoku puzzles, literary events","site_title":"Books news and book reviews","headline":"Books","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/books"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/books/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Books","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Books","order":{"toprail":2008,"ellipsis":2008},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/arts","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Cleveland arts & culture news. Find show reviews, blogs, and art event listings of the Cleveland Orchestra, dance, theater, and fine arts at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Cleveland arts, Cleveland Orchestra, Ohio arts, Ohio culture, Cleveland dance","site_title":"Cleveland & Northeast Ohio Arts & Performing Arts","headline":"Arts","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/arts"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/arts/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Arts","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Arts","order":{"toprail":2009,"ellipsis":2009},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/onstage","site":{"site_description":"Cleveland theater news, reviews and previews from The Plain Dealer.","site_keywords":"PlayhouseSquare, Cleveland playhouse, Great Lakes theater festival, ohio theater, community theater, theater reviews, Playhouse square Cleveland","site_title":"Cleveland Play House, PlayhouseSquare and all things theater in Ohio | On Stage","headline":"On Stage: Cleveland Theater News","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/onstage"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/onstage/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Theater","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Theater","order":{"toprail":2010,"ellipsis":2010},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/friday","site":{"site_description":"Cleveland, OH Friday Magazine. Your weekly guide to Cleveland, OH movies, arts, concerts, clubs, restaurants and nightlife.","site_keywords":"Cleveland OH entertainment, friday magazine, weekend events, weekend guide, arts and entertainment, restaurants, nightclubs, concerts and nightlife","site_title":"Friday Magazine: movies, arts, concerts, clubs, shop talk, after dark, comedy","headline":"Friday!","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/friday"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/friday/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Friday!","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Friday!","order":{"toprail":2011,"ellipsis":2011},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/people","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest celebrity news and gossip. Find out what's new in Hollywood and today's pop culture at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Celebrity news, celebrity gossip, pop culture, Hollywood news, celebrity gossip blog, latest celebrity news, celeb","site_title":"Celebrity News, Gossip, and Pop culture with The Plain Dealer","headline":"People: Celebrities and Hollywood News","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/people"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/people/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"People","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"People","order":{"ellipsis":2012,"toprail":2012},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/entertainment","toprail":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/travel","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest Northeast Ohio , US and International travel news. Browse cleveland.com online travel news site for information and tips on local and world travel guides, travel planning and information.","site_keywords":"travel news, International Travel, travel site, travel guides, world travel, travel planning, travel information, US travel, travel tips, online travel","site_title":"Northeast Ohio, US & International Travel News","headline":"Ohio, U.S. and World Travel","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/travel"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/travel/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Travel","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Travel","order":{"toprail":2013,"ellipsis":2013},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/shopping","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/shopping"],"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/shopping/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Online Shopping","nav_display":null,"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"site":{"site_title":"Online Shopping for the Best Daily Deals","site_keywords":"streaming tv, live tv, online movies, movies, streaming","site_description":"Online shopping for the best deals on the internet.","headline":"Online Shopping and the Best Daily Deals","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Shopping","order":{"ellipsis":2019,"toprail":2014},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/entertainment","toprail":"/entertainment"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/style","site":{"site_description":"Get the latest fashion, style and beauty tips and articles from cleveland.com. Your guide for fashion shopping in Cleveland, Ohio.","site_keywords":"Fashion style, Fashion tips, fashion news, fashion articles, style tips, fashion advice, beauty tips, fashion shopping","site_title":"Fashion & Style | Fashion news, tips & articles for Cleveland, OH","headline":"Fashion & Style","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/style"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/style/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Style","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Link"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Style","order":{"toprail":2015,"ellipsis":2014},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/entertainment","ellipsis":"/entertainment","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/entertainment","/"],"ellipsis":["/entertainment","/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/advice","_admin":{"commercial_node":null,"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/advice"],"tracking_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/advice/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Advice","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"site":{"site_title":"Advice | Columns on family relationships, marriage, dating, etiquette & more","site_keywords":"advice columns, advice, marriage advice, relationships advice, dating advice, family advice, etiquette advice, national advice columns","site_description":"Read advice columns from cleveland.com and syndicated columnists on relationships, family, etiquette and more.","headline":"Advice","site_section":"Life and Culture"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Advice","parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","toprail":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"toprail":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","order":{"ellipsis":1012,"toprail":1012},"children":[]},{"_id":"link-JBPNPBJGRZDHFAY32WMH6WCQ5E","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Puzzles and Comics","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/puzzles/","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1013},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-obituaries","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Obituaries","url":"https://obits.cleveland.com/us/obituaries/cleveland/browse","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1014},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-jobs","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Jobs","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/jobs/","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1015},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-autos","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Autos","url":"http://autos.cleveland.com/","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1016},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/followus","site":{"site_description":null,"site_keywords":null,"site_title":null,"headline":null,"site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/followus"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Follow Us","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Follow Us","order":{"toprail":1017},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"link-visit_our_facebook_page","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Visit our Facebook Page","url":"http://www.facebook.com/pages/clevelandcom/48573742500","parent":{"toprail":"/followus"},"order":{"toprail":2001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-follow_us_on_twitter","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Follow us on Twitter","url":"http://twitter.com/clevelanddotcom","parent":{"toprail":"/followus"},"order":{"toprail":2002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-visit_us_on_google_plus","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Visit us on Google Plus","url":"https://plus.google.com/u/0/b/107235278707360504631/107235278707360504631/posts","parent":{"toprail":"/followus"},"order":{"toprail":2003},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"link-8RCBXJZH7H3QK14Z1557UKD4Y0","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Public Notices","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/public-notices/public-notice","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1018},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/realestate-news","site":{"site_description":"Northeast Ohio's home, neighborhood and community news and information","site_keywords":"Ohio real estate, Cleveland real estate, cleveland ohio real estate, cleveland community, cleveland ohio neighborhoods, real estate news, community news, construction news, neighborhood information, home information","site_title":"Real Estate News","headline":"Real Estate News","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/realestate-news"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/realestate-news/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Real Estate News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Real Estate News","order":{"ellipsis":1041,"toprail":1019},"parent":{"default":"/","ellipsis":"/","hamburger-menu":"/","toprail":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"ellipsis":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[],"toprail":["/"]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"/classifieds","site":{"site_description":null,"site_keywords":null,"site_title":null,"headline":null,"site_section":"Classifieds - Jobs"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/classifieds"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Classifieds","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Classifieds","order":{"toprail":1020},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"link-UNE8C40ZC13C5AYJ5QBT9JMZRC","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Homes for Sale","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/real-estate","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-MVT1ZCDGG5787CGA6WPW0GM6NR","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"For Rent","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/rentals","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-pets","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Pets","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/marketplace/cleveland/category/pets","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-for_sale","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"For Sale","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/marketplace/cleveland/category/for%20sale","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2004},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-garage_sales","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Garage Sales","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/marketplace/cleveland/category/garage%20sale/estate%20sale/auctions","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2005},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-celebrations","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Celebrations","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/marketplace/cleveland/category/celebrations","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2006},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-fraud_prevention","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Fraud Prevention","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/placead/fraud_prevention/","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2007},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-place_an_ad","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Place or Manage an Ad","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/placead/","parent":{"toprail":"/classifieds"},"order":{"toprail":2008},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"link-762MIDU3NVEYHC75WFQ32UJGFM","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Advertise with us","url":"https://www.advance-ohio.com/contact?utm_source=cleveland.com&utm_medium=hamburger&utm_campaign=advertise","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1021},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-07Q5U682JN4ED2YE7GBZK2KK9M","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Mobile Apps","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/mobile-device/","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1022},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-HN2Y01ET6D29KFZKU7XGQM7PJR","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Email Newsletters","url":"https://link.cleveland.com/join/6fe/signup","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1023},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-WNUHYHLXHBGK5CWWUCKKKNBYWQ","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Advance Ohio Events","url":"https://events.cleveland.com/home","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1024},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-T3YEFDZVT5HQXFB3MRZI7YY4HY","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Newspapers.com Archive","url":"https://archives.cleveland.com/?utm_campaign=toprail&utm_source=web","parent":{"toprail":"/"},"order":{"toprail":1025},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},"expires":1766050748906,"lastModified":1766050448861},"{\"hierarchy\":\"editions\",\"site\":\"cleveland\"}":{"data":{"_website":"cleveland","_id":"/","name":"cleveland.com","node_type":"section","children":[]},"expires":1766050748057,"lastModified":1766050448005},"{\"hierarchy\":\"subnav-news\",\"site\":\"cleveland\"}":{"data":{"_website":"cleveland","_id":"/","name":"cleveland.com","node_type":"section","children":[]},"expires":1766050642370,"lastModified":1766050342331},"{\"hierarchy\":\"footer\",\"site\":\"cleveland\"}":{"data":{"_website":"cleveland","_id":"/","name":"cleveland.com","node_type":"section","children":[{"_id":"/footer","name":"Footer Menu","parent":{"default":"/","footer":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"node_type":"section","inactive":false,"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Footer Column 0","parent":{"default":"/footer","footer":"/footer","hamburger-menu":"/footer"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0,"footer":2001},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"About Us","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0","footer":"/footer-column-0","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0,"footer":3001},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"About Us (Column 0)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0","/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-about-us-advertise-with-us","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Advertise with us","url":"https://www.advance-ohio.com/contact?utm_source=cleveland.com&utm_medium=footer&utm_campaign=advertise","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":2},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-about-us-about-cleveland-com","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"About Cleveland.com","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/about-us/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":0},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-about-us-about-advance-ohio","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"About Advance Ohio","url":"https://www.advance-ohio.com/about/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":1},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"About Us (Column 1)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0","/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-about-us-contact-us","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Contact Us","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/interact/2018/10/contact_us.html","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-about-us-career-opportunities","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Career Opportunities","url":"https://www.advance-ohio.com/careers/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":1,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-494X9MJQVD2TN1W2TTCZRHT6J0","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Delivery Opportunities","url":"https://www.plaindealer.com/circulation/independent-contractors/","parent":{"footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1"},"order":{"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-about-us-audience-faq","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Audience FAQ","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/digitalsubscription/faq/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":3,"footer":5004},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-KKQDNZXRJBEFXNWBNZH5JY2N7A","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Accessibility Statement","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/accessibility/","parent":{"footer":"/footer-column-0/section-about-us/double/col-1"},"order":{"footer":5005},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single","navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"_admin":{"alias_ids":[],"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Subscriptions","order":{"default":1,"footer":3002,"hamburger-menu":1},"parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0","footer":"/footer-column-0","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0"},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0","navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"_admin":{"alias_ids":[],"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Subscriptions (Column 0)","order":{"default":0},"parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single"},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0","/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-GTET8R8J451PBC35CGTFP7WQW8","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"cleveland.com","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/subscribe/","parent":{"footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0"},"order":{"footer":5001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-subscribe-the-plain-dealer","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"The Plain Dealer","url":"https://subscribe.plaindealer.com/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-subscribe-enewsletters","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Newsletters","url":"https://link.cleveland.com/join/6fe/signup","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":2,"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-subscribe-sun-news","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sun News","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/interact/2018/10/contact_us.html","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscribe/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":1,"footer":5004},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single","navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"_admin":{"alias_ids":[],"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Already a Subscriber","order":{"default":2,"footer":3003,"hamburger-menu":2},"parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0","footer":"/footer-column-0","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0"},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0","navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"_admin":{"alias_ids":[],"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Already a Subscriber (Column 0)","order":{"default":0},"parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single"},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"],"footer":["/footer","/footer-column-0","/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-subscriber-service-make-a-payment","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Make a Payment","url":"https://myaccount.cleveland.com/SecurePage/Payment.aspx","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":5},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-subscriber-service-pick-up-the-plain-dealer","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Manage your Subscription","url":"https://myaccount.cleveland.com/Securepage/dashboard.aspx","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":2},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-subscriber-service-place-a-vacation-hold","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Place a Vacation Hold","url":"https://myaccount.cleveland.com/securepage/VacationStop.aspx","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":4},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-subscriber-service-report-a-delivery-issue","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Delivery Feedback","url":"https://myaccount.cleveland.com/securepage/MissedPaper.aspx","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-0/section-subscriber-service/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":3},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-1","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Footer Column 1","parent":{"default":"/footer","footer":"/footer","hamburger-menu":"/footer"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1,"footer":2002},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Cleveland.com Sections","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1","footer":"/footer-column-1","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Cleveland.com Sections (Column 0)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-news","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"News","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/news/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-sports","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sports","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/sports/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":1,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-entertainment","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Entertainment","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/entertainment/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":3,"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-politics","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Politics","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/open/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":5,"footer":5004},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-opinion","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Opinion","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/opinion/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":6,"footer":5005},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"/community","site":{"site_description":"Ohio breaking news, events, businesses, classifieds, sports, photos, videos and more. Comment on the news and join forum at cleveland.com.","site_keywords":"Ohio, local news, breaking news","site_title":"Northeast Ohio Community News","headline":"Community","site_section":"News"},"_admin":{"default_content":null,"alias_ids":["/community"],"tracking_node":null,"commercial_node":null,"url_path":"https://www.cleveland.com/community/"},"navigation":{"nav_title":"Local News","nav_display":"true","is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Both"},"_website":"cleveland","name":"Community News","order":{"toprail":1005,"ellipsis":1028,"footer":5006,"native-app-news":1013},"parent":{"default":"/","toprail":"/","ellipsis":"/","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","native-app-news":"/","hamburger-menu":"/"},"ancestors":{"default":[],"toprail":["/"],"ellipsis":["/"],"footer":["/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"],"native-app-news":["/"],"hamburger-menu":[]},"inactive":false,"node_type":"section","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-living","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Living","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/living/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":4,"footer":5007},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-2RYB75M48N7WVC2RR8Y3TJQB0R","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Betting","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/betting/","parent":{"footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"footer":5008},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-rentals","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Rentals","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/rentals","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":4,"footer":5009},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Cleveland.com Sections (Column 1)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-obituaries","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Obituaries","url":"https://obits.cleveland.com/us/obituaries/cleveland/browse","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-jobs","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Jobs","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/jobs/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":1,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-deals-in-your-area","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Deals in Your Area","url":"https://link.cleveland.com/join/6fe/signup","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":8,"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-classifieds","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Classifieds","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":5,"footer":5004},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-autos","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Autos","url":"https://autos.cleveland.com/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":2,"footer":5005},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-cleveland-com-sections-real-estate","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Real Estate","url":"https://classifieds.cleveland.com/cleveland/category/real-estate","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-cleveland-com-sections/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":3,"footer":5006},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Mobile","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1","footer":"/footer-column-1","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":2,"hamburger-menu":2},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single/col-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Mobile (Column 0)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-mobile-mobile-apps","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Mobile Apps","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/mobile-device/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-mobile/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":0},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Your Regional News Pages","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1","footer":"/footer-column-1","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Your Regional News Pages (Column 0)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-your-regional-news-pages-lakewood","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Lakewood","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/lakewood/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":2,"footer":5001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-your-regional-news-pages-beachwood","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Beachwood","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/beachwood/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-your-regional-news-pages-brunswick","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Brunswick","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/brunswick/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":1,"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Your Regional News Pages (Column 1)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-your-regional-news-pages-strongsville","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Strongsville","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/strongsville/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":1,"footer":5001},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-your-regional-news-pages-parma-parma-heights","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Parma & Parma Heights","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/topic/parma/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-your-regional-news-pages-more-communities","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"More Communities","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/community/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-1/section-your-regional-news-pages/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":2,"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-2","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Footer Column 2","parent":{"default":"/footer","footer":"/footer","hamburger-menu":"/footer"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":2,"hamburger-menu":2,"footer":2003},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"More on Cleveland.com","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2","footer":"/footer-column-2","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-2"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0,"footer":3001},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"More on Cleveland.com (Column 1)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-sponsor-content","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sponsor Content","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/sponsor-content-index/?prx_adpz=1109","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":5},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-sell-your-car","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sell your car","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/placead/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":2},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-post-a-job","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Post a job","url":"https://hiring.cleveland.com/purchase/post-now/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":0},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-sitemap-search","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sitemap & search","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/search/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":4},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-post-a-classified-ad","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Post a classified ad","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/placead/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":1},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-sell-rent-your-home","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Sell/rent your home","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/placead/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-1"},"order":{"default":3},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"More on Cleveland.com (Column 0)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-more-on-cleveland-com-videos","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Videos","url":"https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJkc1COQO0WiZ2CI7dRdwAQ","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-0"},"order":{"default":0,"footer":5002},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-HZVCH31YU93C1A8EF743UCU0A4","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Newspapers.com Archive","url":"https://archives.cleveland.com/?utm_campaign=footer&utm_source=web","parent":{"footer":"/footer-column-2/section-more-on-cleveland-com/double/col-0"},"order":{"footer":5003},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]},{"_id":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Follow Us","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2","footer":"/footer-column-2","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-2"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":1,"hamburger-menu":1,"footer":3002},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0","node_type":"section","inactive":false,"name":"Follow Us (Column 0)","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single","hamburger-menu":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single"},"navigation":{"is_this_a_link_or_a_section":"Section","nav_title":null,"nav_display":null},"order":{"default":0},"_website":"cleveland","ancestors":{"default":["/"],"hamburger-menu":["/"]},"children":[{"_id":"link-footer-follow-us-twitter","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Twitter","url":"https://twitter.com/clevelanddotcom","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":0},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-follow-us-pinterest","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Pinterest","url":"https://www.pinterest.com/clevelanddotcom/","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":4},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-follow-us-facebook","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Facebook","url":"https://www.facebook.com/pages/clevelandcom/48573742500","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":1},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-footer-follow-us-instagram","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"Instagram","url":"https://instagram.com/clevelanddotcom","parent":{"default":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0","footer":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0"},"order":{"default":3},"node_type":"link","children":[]},{"_id":"link-WWY6N04W253HKA7F8BH44B0TK8","_website":"cleveland","display_name":"RSS","url":"https://www.cleveland.com/arc/outboundfeeds/rss/?outputType=xml","parent":{"footer":"/footer-column-2/section-follow-us/single/col-0"},"order":{"footer":5005},"node_type":"link","children":[]}]}]}]}]}]},"expires":1766050747497,"lastModified":1766050447441}},"weather-api":{"{\"endpoint\":\"3day\",\"location\":null}":{"data":{"current":{"classname":"mostly-sunny","conditions":"Mostly Sunny","conditions_short":"Mostly Sunny","icon_code":"02","location":"-","temp_hilo":"","temperature":"-","zip_code":"-"},"tomorrow":{"classname":"mostly-sunny","conditions":"Mostly Sunny","conditions_short":"Mostly Sunny","high_temp":"-","icon_code":"02","low_temp":"-","temp_hilo":"High","temperature":"-"},"tonight":{"classname":"mostly-sunny","conditions":"Mostly Sunny","conditions_short":"Mostly Sunny","high_temp":"-","icon_code":"02","low_temp":"-","temp_hilo":"Low","temperature":"-"},"_id":"8f418281992fc16b2aa877fd7d3bf8a900ea71ec5bf5b1c7cec4033e46380f53"},"expires":1766050742104,"lastModified":1766050442046}},"trackonomics-domains-api":{"undefined":{"data":{"detectionKey":"(fubo.tv|(pxf|sjv)\\.io|(goto.target|go.web.plus.espn)\\.com|(tnu8|fanatics.93n6tx|k77v|775j|vwz6|ue7a|i8h2|am3t9s|uym8|evyy)\\.net|(c1\\.dealnews\\.com)|(go\\.redirectingat\\.com)|(go\\.skimresources\\.com)|(fave\\.co)|(go\\.[a-zA-Z0-9].*?\\.com(\\/?)\\?id=[0-9].+?X[0-9].+?&)|(amazon\\.[\\S]*?\\/(dp|gp)\\/[\\S]*?tag=)|(amazon\\.[\\S]*?\\/[\\S]*?\\?[\\S]*?tag=[a-zA-Z0-9-]+\\-(\\d{2}))|(\\/amzn\\.)|(\\.amazon-adsystem\\.com)|(click\\.linksynergy\\.com)|(linksynergy\\.walmart\\.com)|(anrdoezrs\\.net)|(jdoqocy\\.com)|(tqlkg\\.com)|(tkqlhce\\.com)|(kqzyfj\\.com)|(ftjcfx\\.com)|(lduhtrp\\.net)|(jqoqocy\\.com)|(Kqzfj\\.com)|(dpbolvw\\.net)|(qksrv\\.net)|(awin1\\.com)|(pepperjamnetwork\\.com)|(pjtra\\.com\\/t\\/)|(gopjn\\.com\\/t\\/)|(pjatr\\.com\\/t\\/)|(pntra\\.com\\/t\\/)|(pntrs\\.com\\/t\\/)|(pntrac\\.com\\/t\\/)|(\\/(c)\\/([0-9]+)\\/([0-9]+)\\/([0-9]+))|(prf\\.hn\\/click)|(prf\\.hn\\/l)|(shop\\.).*camref\\:)","_id":"4979dc5c4b2908667e7c871098450fa04564eaba937ecc8e32273efa336c4472"},"expires":1766125440878,"lastModified":1766039039983}},"affiliate-marketing-config":{"undefined":{"data":{"affiliate_only_authors":["adill","albert","amanda-edelman","amyhavin","apalya","arianatourangeau","bmanley","cayden-steele","dgeske","dhalibey","dhockens","jchandler","jennamalinowski","jessica-day","jhowell","joey-aliberti","johnholland","jrejent","khadrice-rollins","madisonkemeny","mdunaj","mdwortz","niuzzolino","rachelmorrison","rfenbers","tkuehl","tlagrone","yliwanag"],"affiliate_nonexclusive_authors":["ahernand","aknudson","anniebarron","asuarez","bsaxelson","bsherman","carolbenanti","chopkin2","csheldon","gracelynsantos","hdomin","jdamodio","jhumburg","jimmy-hascup","jmorona","jodom","jsimmons","kldavis","krodriguez","leadagore","mgoul","mheim","mrose","mswanson","nickjomalley","rnovozinsky","seadams","tbrown","timbielik","tsanzo","vrosenthal"],"product_category_exclude_sections":["sports"],"trackonomics_tags":["@trx"],"trackonomics_sections":["live-entertainment","shopping","shopping-deals","sports","sports/event-tickets","tv"],"trackonomics_exclude_sections":["betting","casinos","fantasy","lottery","sweepstakes"],"trackonomics_authors":["adill","ahernand","aknudson","albert","amanda-edelman","amyhavin","anniebarron","apalya","arianatourangeau","asuarez","bmanley","bsaxelson","bsherman","carolbenanti","cayden-steele","chopkin2","csheldon","dgeske","dhalibey","dhockens","gracelynsantos","hdomin","jchandler","jdamodio","jennamalinowski","jessica-day","jhowell","jhumburg","jimmy-hascup","jmorona","jodom","joey-aliberti","johnholland","jrejent","jsimmons","khadrice-rollins","kldavis","krodriguez","leadagore","madisonkemeny","mdunaj","mdwortz","mgoul","mheim","mrose","mswanson","nickjomalley","niuzzolino","rachelmorrison","rfenbers","rnovozinsky","seadams","tbrown","timbielik","tkuehl","tlagrone","tsanzo","vrosenthal","yliwanag"],"web_category_sections":["betting","entertainment"],"_id":"f170b26eff9c4a1d02d9183dbe0081280187aebf2450f47c79b9fa5310ec5156"},"expires":1766050666543,"lastModified":1760462888000}},"rollcall-active-poll-data":{"undefined":{"data":{"activePollData":{"14":{"startDate":1600056000000,"endDate":1897275600000,"affiliates":["lehighvalleylive","lonestarlive"],"articles":["4AHJ7RWD4ZEOBGTXQV6UGCBTOY","XPQSBA6GUVBXBFLNP32LUWPPSA"],"categories":[],"customCategories":[],"customEntities":[],"segments":[],"headlineSubstrings":[],"showOnBettingPage":false,"showOnRegularArticle":true,"tags":[]}},"_id":"4f540aa8fe9cf1e16d4069e94d1e1bf370f0761c76cba70410f1c97b59f94d57"},"expires":1766050730301,"lastModified":1766048439000}},"author-api":{"{\"id\":\"andrewjtobias\"}":{"data":{"_id":"andrewjtobias","status":true,"bio":"","byline":"Andrew J. Tobias, cleveland.com","firstName":"Andrew ","lastName":"Tobias","twitter":"andrewjtobias","education":[],"mt_author_id":"11064223","podcasts":[],"last_updated_date":"2024-01-31T13:11:04.216Z","books":[],"facebook":"https://www.facebook.com/andrewjtobias","awards":[],"email":"atobias@cleveland.com","image":"https://author-service-images-prod-us-east-1.publishing.aws.arc.pub/advancelocal/42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png","middleName":"J.","location":"Columbus, Ohio","role":"Chief politics reporter","longBio":"Andrew Tobias has worked in journalism since 2008, and has covered government and politics during that time at the local, state and federal levels. Some of his major assignments include the 2016 Republican National Convention in Cleveland and U.S. Senate campaigns in 2018 and 2022. He has received numerous awards from the Associated Press of Ohio for investigative reporting and news reporting, and regularly appears on radio and television to discuss Ohio politics. He previously worked for newspapers in Dayton and Delaware (Ohio.) He is a 2008 graduate of Otterbein University and a lifelong Ohio resident.","url":"https://author-service-images-prod-us-east-1.publishing.aws.arc.pub/advancelocal/42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png","auth":{"1":"ef2dfd67a713e185ecabfedbc7d4ee2ed14a2b58821f8895c97ba551a139f77e"},"resized_urls":{"x_small":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/https%3A%2F%2Fauthor-service-images-prod-us-east-1.publishing.aws.arc.pub%2Fadvancelocal%2F42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png?auth=ef2dfd67a713e185ecabfedbc7d4ee2ed14a2b58821f8895c97ba551a139f77e&width=180&smart=true&quality=90","medium":"https://www.cleveland.com/resizer/v2/https%3A%2F%2Fauthor-service-images-prod-us-east-1.publishing.aws.arc.pub%2Fadvancelocal%2F42792c1b-bd53-40ee-97a4-b87cc1ddb88b.png?auth=ef2dfd67a713e185ecabfedbc7d4ee2ed14a2b58821f8895c97ba551a139f77e&width=510&smart=true&quality=90"}},"expires":1766050838463,"lastModified":1766050538357}}};Fusion.layout="article-beta";Fusion.metas={"pageType":{"value":"article","html":false},"isArticleBeta":{"value":"true","html":true}};Fusion.outputType="default";Fusion.template="template/tvVfno7KLrdTNmVIs";Fusion.tree={"collection":"layouts","type":"article-beta","props":{"collection":"layouts","type":"article-beta","id":"article-beta","childProps":[{"collection":"sections","id":0},{"collection":"sections","id":1},{"collection":"sections","id":2},{"collection":"sections","id":3},{"collection":"sections","id":4},{"collection":"sections","id":5},{"collection":"sections","id":6}]},"children":[{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":0},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"utilities/google-tag-manager","props":{"collection":"features","type":"utilities/google-tag-manager","id":"f0fNTqVicgV98O9","name":"GTM","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"utilities/clavis","props":{"collection":"features","type":"utilities/clavis","id":"f0f1mattcgV98al","name":"Clavis","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/sophi","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/sophi","id":"f0fllKVwcgV98Di","name":"Sophi","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/module-tracking","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/module-tracking","id":"f0fqleZsNRQrccI","name":"Module Tracking","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/toprail","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/toprail","id":"f0fGzuOAcgV98qY","name":"Toprail","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{"items":{}},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"section/alert","props":{"collection":"features","type":"section/alert","id":"f0fwh55ZaBMlXF","name":"section alert","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{"type":"news-promo","headline":"Family Sharing is here! Subscribe to Premium Access for $5","link":"https://www.cleveland.com/digitalsubscription/inline/"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}}]},{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":1},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0fJCsVMcgV98Nc","name":"Ad (Toprail)","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"adType":"topRail-Below-Flex"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0fqi70RJZos1mY","name":"Ad (Popup)","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{"adType":"popup"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}}]},{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":2},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0fXCdmQcgV98ho","name":"Ad (Toprail Below Sponsor)","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"adType":"topRail-Below-Sponsor","pbInternal_cloneId":"f0f2OIGE79UW1to"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article/label","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article/label","id":"f0fGJbNTcgV98tc","name":"Label","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/live-indicator","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/live-indicator","id":"f0fjM8SGbyQu1rQ","name":"global live indicator","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article/headline","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article/headline","id":"f0fdgLsWcgV98hO","name":"article headline","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/dateline","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/dateline","id":"f0fd9oGYcgV98uY","name":"Dateline","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}}]},{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":3},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"article/multimedia-main","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article/multimedia-main","id":"f0fEBxY1dgV98H6","name":"MMM","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/sharebar-beta","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/sharebar-beta","id":"f0fxO9YQBB1j1Ao","name":"global sharebar beta","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{"showGifting":true,"showFacebook":true,"showX":true,"showSaveArticles":true},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/byline","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/byline","id":"f0fQazd7dgV98lh","name":"Byline","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article-beta/content-blocking","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article-beta/content-blocking","id":"f0fbilv9dgV98I5","name":"Content Blocker","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article-beta/trackonomics-link-wrapper","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article-beta/trackonomics-link-wrapper","id":"f0fGo1aAd1uF1df","name":"article-beta trackonomics link wrapper","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article-beta/cta","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article-beta/cta","id":"f0ffEBHbdgV98A9","name":"CTA","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/headliner-podcast-widget","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/headliner-podcast-widget","id":"f0frX8yD5iL3b3F","name":"global headliner podcast widget","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article/rollcall","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article/rollcall","id":"f0fxq2kp4XcZ5xo","name":"article rollcall","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/author-bio-enhanced","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/author-bio-enhanced","id":"f0fQtcCoEyNjvY","name":"global author bio enhanced","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article/ai-disclosure","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article/ai-disclosure","id":"f0fY8APlaKzs37l","name":"article ai disclosure","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"article/skimlinks","props":{"collection":"features","type":"article/skimlinks","id":"f0fmWdVddgV98PK","name":"Skimlinks","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0fHIF4hdgV98nu","name":"Taboola","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"adType":"taboola-below-article"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/aff-marketing-click-trk","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/aff-marketing-click-trk","id":"f0fFO1xRtFnL2t","name":"global aff marketing click trk","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}}]},{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":4},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0faboBndgV98HW","name":"Ad (Right Rail Top)","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"adType":"rightRail-Top-300xFlex"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0f9EsVpdgV98lP","name":"Taboola","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"adType":"taboola-rightRail"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0fGSB1sdgV98Hq","name":"Ad (Right Rail Bottom)","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"rightRailstickyAd":true,"adType":"rightRail-Bottom-300xFlex"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{"items":{}},"variants":{}}}]},{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":5},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"global/footer","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/footer","id":"f0fXMB7gLtZC63U","name":"global footer","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{"showLinks":true,"showAffLogo":true},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}}]},{"collection":"sections","props":{"collection":"sections","id":6},"children":[{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/ads","id":"f0fteRuxdgV98TA","name":"Ad (Adhesion)","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":false},"customFields":{"adType":"mobile-bottom-adhesion"},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/anchor-modal","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/anchor-modal","id":"f0fPQHICdgV98XS","name":"Anchor Modal","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}},{"collection":"features","type":"global/bottom-fixed-modal","props":{"collection":"features","type":"global/bottom-fixed-modal","id":"f0f27AJ1B8uIbkP","name":"global bottom fixed modal","contentConfig":{"contentService":"","contentConfigValues":{},"inherit":true},"customFields":{},"displayProperties":{},"localEdits":{},"variants":{}}}]}]};Fusion.spa=false;Fusion.spaEnabled=false;</script></body></html>